Tess,
I sent a message to babypips today about partnering with my company to build a review site. I hear what you're saying about keeping the riff raff out, and I think there is a pretty simple way to do it - make it a requirement that they have to have 5 posts here at this forum before they can submit a review. The posts won't be allowed to one-liner "Right on, dude!" type of posts. They will have to be thought out and contribute to the discussion. Once those 5 posts are complete the babypips forum name (and if the admin of babypips can do it, the IP address) will go in the reviewer's information where admin can see it. We could also get a little more ridiculous and make people send in a copy of their utility bill, but I don't think that would fly.
Suggestions?
(Also, if anyone reading this thinks my idea is a good one, put some pressure
on the admin here to help me set it up. If babypips decides to not partner with it maybe you all know someone else who can build a website.)