I think that multiple time frames will almost always give different signals. That's the nature of the beast.

I'm afraid I'm not going to be much help to refine your system. I abandoned the multiple indicators and multiple time frames because I found them confusing, probably for the same reason that you're talking about. I also used to go to a lower time frame for entry, but found that annoying, too.

So, I'm now using strictly MA crossovers, getting the signal, entering, and exiting on the same time frame.

I find it easier for me because I only have to worry about the signals for one time frame and two indicators.

Terry