View Single Post
  #62 (permalink)  
Old 03-23-2008, 06:29 PM
uptick's Avatar
uptick uptick is offline
Senior Member
 

Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 207
Send a message via AIM to uptick Send a message via MSN to uptick Send a message via Yahoo to uptick
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by didjerdu View Post
FX-

With all due respect, you've made a commitment to post your trades but don't want to explain how it's done? Why bother? What have you to gain by posting trades without sharing how you came to make these trades? I don't understand your motives. Nobody expects you to sell anything here. There are several people who would like to know HOW you've arrived at your decisions to make and take a trade. Is that fair? Or am I overreacting?
S.


There's nothing wrong in keeping a journal here on babypips... many people do it.

In my opinion, just because FXTH is having great success DOES NOT mean that he/she has to give up his/her strategy and share it with the world. As a trader myself, I know it can take years for you to figure out a successful strategy. For me to then "have to" share it with everyone is not quite fair, nor should people start trashing FXTH just because he/she doesn't give away his/her strategy.

I'm at least thankful that FXTH is sharing his/her entries...If these results continue, i'll be trading it putting some real money to work.

I wish FXTH continued success.
Reply With Quote