Hi,
No - I never said that I would only trade with the main trend (that was someone else). I was going to have a look to see whether or not it would be viable to ensure that the Monthly, Weekly, and Daily Parabolic SAR was going in the same direction but upon further investigation it would appear that the chances of this happening often enough to provide valid entry points on the Daily charts are not very high. While I'm sure that there is no doubt that if you were able to find that Parabolic SAR on the Monthly, Weekly, and Daily charts was moving in the same direction your profits would be all but 'guaranteed' but I think that you would make very few trades over a very long period of time. I'm prepared to, and have the capital to be able to take the 'whipsaws', to trade only the Daily charts, based pureley on signals given by Parabolic SAR regardless of the direction of any other trends on any other timeframe. Put it this way - I have never done it any other way - and it still works for me.
What I did say though is that IF you needed confirmation from a longer timeframe the only way that I could see that you could get this confirmation is to look at ONLY ONE higher timeframe i.e. you could verify the Weekly trend, and then trade only the Daily, you could verify the Daily, and then trade only the four hour, etc. etc. etc. Trying to get confirmation from the Monthly, Weekly, and Daily would, once again, in my opinion, result in very few trades - and - if you're wrong - you'd have to wait far too long to make up your initial loss and then turn a profit thereafter.
Regards,
Dale.
|