Quote:
Originally Posted by andyk
Pipalots modifications are excellent
However, with regard to the missed buy signal - the indicator was only looking to sell at that time. I get a little confused with where the trendline is drawn on the 15min chart - below price means sell, above price means buy, which seems the wrong way round to me - uptrends should be supported and downtrends should be resisted.
Also - looking through the code, the definition of 4Hr trend depends on MA cross, MACD and stochs. There has been talk about this before I think, but my interpretation is that the 4HR trend is ONLY DECIDED BY THE 5EMA/10EMA CROSS. This seems to be all PipSurfer is interested in on the Cowabunga daily reports.
I have changed this in the code, and will move the trendline indicator on 15min chart so that if we're looking to SELL, its above price, and looking to BUY, its below price.
This was very easy to do but if anyone wants me to post these changes let me know. I'd also be interested to know if I've done the right thing!
|
No, in this missed trigger, the trend was up. It should have caught it, and it didn't.
EDIT 11-26-07 ==> I originally said MACD and not RSI in this post, my mistake. someone corrected me several posts later, but I wanted to come back and correct it here for those who are reading it later so as not to confuse anyone.
I also thought that PipSurfer must be using only the 5EMA cross on the 4hr for the trend. So I looked inside the indicator file to see if it was also looking at RSI and Stochs to determine the trend, and it is.
But in looking thru the blog that originally describes the Cowabunga method, BigPippin WAS looking at Stochs and RSI on the 4hr as well. Just that PipSurfer's feed has both the stochs and the RSI in the correct position at the 5EMA cross on the 4hr.
The problem with this MT4 indicator is that on the bar where the 5EMA cross occurs, if the RSI and the stochs don't also show the trend change in the SAME BAR, then the indicator won't pick up the trend reversal. It will then stay in the wrong trend until the next change and the next change back.
I don't know how to fix this, so I just removed the Stoch and the RSI portions of it, and now mine shows trend ONLY on the 5EMA cross on the 4hr. It's up to me to check it and be sure I have a true trend, but at least this way I get the intended signal more of the time.
I don't care about which side the line is on, but I would be curious how that's done; so if you do post it I would like to look thru it.
Jeff