Viso - YW!
andyk - Yes, you're right in MACD is NOT a req for the trend. My mistake. It's RSI I forgot.
Quote:
|
Perhaps we should say, regardless of EMA crosses, if EMA5 > EMA 10, and stochs are heading up, and RSI >50 we're in uptrend. The converse for downtrend, and if any of the 3 conditions doesn't match, we have no trend.
|
Yes, exactly.
I think the problem with the indicator is that if the RSI and Stoch requirement are not met on the SAME BAR as the 5EMA cross, it misses the trend change altogether. With
NO ill will toward pipalot for making it!
And yes, if it can be made so that ANY TIME that all 3 indicators are in line, it changes the trend, then I think we'll have exactly what we want. I don't have a clue how to program that, if you do then yes please.
Stochs I do not fully understand, and don't know what goes into the two lines that you see. But I do recall someone asking about whether BOTH lines must be trending, or whether BOTH lines must be out of overbought/sold territory. I seem to recall that BigPippin or PipSurfer said that only one of the two stoch lines must agree with all other indicators.
Don't know if that helps anything.
But yes, if you can make it so it indicates trend ANY TIME the three indicators agree even if they don't all happen on the same bar, that would be good, I think.
Thanks,
Jeff