COT Report Analysis - a thread on market sentiment

On COT divergence on GBP - this is interesting - the commercials have switched sides, now net long, price up and OI down.

I’ll just quote Williams -

“Price up, OI down is bearish (conventional wisdom) - remember I said conventional. I do not say it is correct.”

“Low OI means the public and funds have lost interest in this particular market. Their attention and money have been diverted elsewhere … the fact that the public are not interested means I should be.”

Williams later quotes some examples " The hefty decrease in OI means that the only buy orders coming in (new trades) were from the smart guys while the large traders were selling short or decreasing their bullishness by not buying.

Again our inside view of the inner workings of the marketplace reveals what is really going on here, and in this case the OI decline is bullish".

Basically Williams is suggesting that when he sees a decline in OI coupled with a marked increase in Commercial buying that, in his words, “a rally is near at hand”.

He suggests the opposite case scenario is where price has been in a rising trend, there is increased OI coupled with an increase of Commercial shorts, then a top may be near at hand.

Edit: Page 91 “opening up on Open Interest”

The idea of the crosses system is based on the 1 minute trader system of Larry Williams.
Step 1: I wrote all the crosses for the currencies we do the COT report for (USD, GBP, CHF, JPY, AUD, NZD and CAD.
Step 2: I wrote the currencies in a another row.
Step 3: I calculated the commercials’ net position of each currency.
Step 4: I calculated the net position of the crosses. Example: I want to know the commercials net position for EURUSD. I simply add the commercials net position on EUR to their net position on USD.
Step 5: I calculated the lowest net position and highest net position for the past 6 months of each cross.
Step 6: I calculated the COT Index value of each cross.
Step 7: I highlight the crosses that are under 20 or above 80. Then I go to my chart.
Step 8: I look for bottoms at the chart using the 1 minute trader. So for example let’s say that GBPJPY gave me a value of 100. This means the pair is at a bottom. So I go to a weekly chart of GBPJPY and plot the 52 week MA. A buy signal is triggered if the value of the MA for the latest week is higher than that of the last two weeks. The opposite (having a value of 20 or lower and an MA lower than the previous two weeks) represents a sell signal.
Step 9: Take the trade on the first minute of the Monday trading session.
Step 10: Close the trade at the last minute of the trading week.

That’s all there is to it really. I have been looking at possible technical entry and exit techniques. But I have not used them for the test yet.

I hope this clears things up.

I absolutely loved your analysis and it really cleared things up for me. My concern though is that commercials themselves have also decreased their positions. Doesn’t that affect our analysis?

I think what Williams is saying that with such a large exodus from the swimming pool it is important to watch what those commercials remaining did, in this case it seems they switched sides and went long.

(For those not having read Williams’ book, he likens OI to swimmers in a pool, the pool is the market and OI are the swimmers (players), a drop in OI and many swimmers got out.)

It will be very interesting to see next Friday’s positions, I would like to see a strengthening of their longs, maybe not as definite as last Friday’s but at least some sort of additional longs - this would help confirm what the fundamental numbers are saying about the UK economy outlook, despite the fall in GBP.

Hi guys,

I did what [B]Mike[/B] suggested last time. I made likes so you guys see I read the post and like them, only cannot answer at the time. Now I made the time. Mike, you answered only for the riddle from Peter. Now my cartoon knowledge is also improved.

[B]Philip[/B], thanks a lot. I wrote down the points. I like for the early phase of the test the entry and exit. It makes it simple for the test, later on we can use other techniques. Now it is enough. Sorry, we move so fast, did you write something about entry also or only hightlighted the two possible exit scenarios until now?

And I also remember what was the other thing in the afternoon what I forgot. It wasn’t a question. I wanted to thank you for your work vocation (not 100% that is the right word). In this thread everyone has his place but you just give me always a huge help and backup. I really believe in the crossover system, highlighted the idea and thought it can work out. Others were busy with course (this is very acceptable!) but you came in, were positive about the idea, helped, brought new ideas and did not let the action “die”. I think the biggest problem is with innovative ideas that no one looks into it, it is not tested and after a time it is forgotten although the work was in it and it might have changed everything. I was/am busy at these times but you did not forget about it, you made the test and continue the work. I am confident with the thread and new ideas because I know even if I am busy or forget something, you are always there to help out. Also when I cannot push the issue further on, you step ahead like it is an intuition and get into the action to push the issue further on. This is great and thanks again!!! Your post was great, I wanted it with steps so I can do exactly the same way the test as you. I go back now and read all post, check in the beginning of the week timingcharts too, and start working on it. I see huge potentials. As you also said, if we do the work we should work now on efficiency. I also think we should continue the testing, looking at maximum drawdowns, optimal lot sizes, entries, exits etc. and when we found it, work will be quite easy and the gain comes. We can name the compact system something like the “MikePhilipRookiePetermaForExchange System”. If flows turn up again we can add his name into it.

Although you explained the system great, I still have 2 question that I need to know. When you wrote down the steps I saw right away the point I did not get the last time. It is the “1 minute trader”. I do not know if it is a charting program, a term, a special forex expression or what exactly. So I do not know what you mean under that and if I can do this step at all. The other thing was about your excel steps. The question is if you calculate and evaluate the values one by one or do you use equations in excel that you just put the position numbers in and it calculates everything? This is very important because the work you do looks huge. If I do it with all alone it takes me I guess at least a day to get the thing first, but later on it would still be 3-4 hours at least every weekend. So I am interested if you do it all the work or you are great at excel. Again, google drive would be good or to know your formulas.

[B]Peter[/B], thanks for the explanation, I guess we are expecting the high quality content you always give to us. Everything was exact, the page numbers included. I like that you wrote it on OI because for me it is just the toughtest part in the book. Philip made a concern, I do it too. Not to question your knowledge but I think we cannot forget in this case something. I am interested about next Friday’s report too. However I am quite sure on OI rise, no matter what. The thing is, the book was looking for the OI examples as great game changers as I remember with the very low readings. I do think we might have a very special case and no game changing at all. This case was “The Vote”. I call it with this name because participants just wanted to get out their money from the uncertain UK. It does not necessary tells us I think a game change, they did not want to be in risk. I can expect the trend going on, both longs and shorts will be adding for both specs and commercials next week and The Vote ended with a “No”. Do not think that I do not find your answer relevant, I give it at least the same as possibility as for my version. I just thought mentioning it, because I think in this case the descrease of OI was dependent on a very special event. We will see what happens.

Maybe you guys are surprised how am I in the thread. I really do not have time but luckily I have internet where I am. The weekend is really tough but I decided after I found net (I am not an iPhone or high level mobile freak so I do not have internet there) that I just sleep less and work with you guys.

Ok guys, I have some thoughts on NZD that I also want to discuss with you, I post it soon.

Hi guys,

I said I write on the NZD in an extra post. The thing is that I see some fundamental and COT divergence.

Since we follow here the COT report we have found some extremes, but these extremes were only extremes compared to the 3-4 months data to follow. So relatively short-term. This time however we are heading quite fast to a 4 year low extreme for the NZD!

Where is the problem? If we are reaching a 4 year extreme, then the chance should be good for a reversal. Now here comes the problem as for a reversal the fundamentals should be supporting the rise I guess.

My view is a short-term fall still, until the COT extreme as diary prices are still falling and AUD is not doing so good either. As rookie or Mike posted once, I think we have seen an article where they wrote that prices for diary will rise in the end of the year. This would come quite good to our COT extreme and might help the reversal! The carry trade is also on the NZD side so a short-term bearish (maybe even 1-2 months) are still in the play and then a reversal based on COT.

Now here comes the problem with the reversal. As there are quite some fundamentals against it. If AUD goes down it is not good for the NZD for sure. USD getting strong and Comms are going down generally which is also not good for the NZD. Data are also not so great which is of course not good for NZD. Not even mentioning if diary prices will not rise.

Usually I feel good about a good with a one direction bias. Here we see many mixed information which makes it harder to decide which way to go. In the current state [I]I still favor short-term downtrend and long-term uptrend[/I]. If some conditions change I stay flexible and “update” my view.

I thought it is important to mention as I am really exited about “our” first really extreme COT signal since the start of the thread. In this excitement I do not forget Philips 1-2 posts; maybe in August when he already highlighted his long-term NZD long view. The data slowly moves to this direction.

So as always, I am looking for your opinion.

Hi Philip,

you work quite a lot already and I do not want that you wake up with a nightmare with the many expectations but I ask from you one more post.

It is about the seasonal trends. You have been writing about your expecatation in August, what might come in September. I did not find the post (went back until 890 so that is why I guess it was probably in August), but as I remember you wrote Comms strength (AUD and NZD mainly) and GBP strength. But I am not sure if it was like this, my memory says it. Now if I am right, I do not want to pick on you (because of the Comms lost), but I do find it important to write us a quick review what exactly the expectations were and how they work out. I do think it is another issue to learn but if we only write about it before the event and comes no evaluation later on than it is a lost discussion before the event. End of September is already there so it might be the right time to analyze it and remember how it worked out, regardless if it is a positive or negative result.

As you guys see, I stayed up with my standard pretty late to contribute here, I try tomorrow abend also to come here for some time.

Cheers

Heys guys!

Here’s what COT looks like as of last tuesday.

I quickly went through some of the posts and saw some of you were well Peter already having a discussion on turn arounds in net positions on some currencies. So let get to it…


The commdolls
AUD, NZD and CAD

Non commercials: Specs have been selling AUD for the 3rd consecutive week as we see them reduce their net positive position and longs on AUD. Last weeks drop was however quite large specs reducing their net positive from 41229 to 22140. AUD has plunged to 0.9148 from 0.9281 against USD. Specs outlook on AUD seems bearish.

Specs have been selling NZD for the 8th consecutive week as they progressively reduce their net positions /longs/ and longs for the 7th consecutive week. We saw quite large change in net position last tuesday specs reducing their net position /longs/ from 9522 to 1120. NZD have plunged from 0.8302 to 0.8217 against the dollar last week. 4 year low net negative reading was at -5530. Is there a room for kiwi dollar to plunge further down at least against the dollar , I would say sure yes. Specs outlook on NZD is bearish.

Specs have reduced their net position /longs/ from 11630 to 7544 on CAD. Just the week prior last week we saw specs adding up on their net position /longs/ and they appeared somewhat bullish on CAD. Not anymore. At least against the dollar. Specs appear rather bearish to neutral on CAD. CAD jumped to 1.1028 from 1.0949 against the dollar last week.

Commercials: Commercials have been on the other hand reducing their net positions /shorts/ on AUD for the 2nd consecutive week. Rather bullish reading. However I want to highlight that it still is net negative and we’re yet to see a transition from negative to positive reading as we have with some currencies that we will later see.

Commercial net position on NZD has turned from net negative /-9702/ to net positive /39/. Commercials have started buying kiwi dollar. As I recall commercials buy when price is down and sell when its high and move the opposite to specs or the trend.

Commercials net position has turned from net negative to positive on CAD. Commercials have started buying CAD the week prior last tuesday commercials net position on CAD was -6359 and last tuesday we saw them turning it all around and now net position stands at 3203. Rather bullish reading.

The majors
GBP and EUR

Non commercials: Specs net position has turned to net positive from net negative on GBP. As of 9th Sep specs net position /longs/ was at 26727 and last week it plunged down to and into the negative zone at -6581. Most of it I suspect was due to Scotland referendum. Spec bulls were pricing in on or just seconds after the no vote came out, we saw pound sterling rising up across the board before giving it all away. So I’m not reading much into this change from net positive to net negative reading. However I do think we can’t be too optimistic on pound sterling neither as general election is coming up in May 2015 and there was slight slowdown in key economic data that was released recently. Scotland referendum may not be the end. And there’s a genuine uncertainty in that regards, politically speaking. That might deter investors away from investing in the UK - decline in pound sterling. And BoE may not start hiking rates until after next general election.

Specs have reduced their net position /shorts/ from -157505 to -137149 on EUR. While they reduced their net negative positions specs still appear very much bearish on EUR. EUR has plunged to 1.2908 from 1.2996 against dollar. Like I said I’ll be bearish on EUR until key economic indicators pick up.

Commercials: Commercials GBP net position has turned from negative /-17678/ to positive /15775/ reading. Commercials have started buying pound sterling. Probably a bargain price to get in pound sterling plunged to 1.6153 from 1.6329. Does it mean that we’ll see pound sterling plunge further down ? probably it will against the dollar.

EUR net position /longs/ has declined once again for the 2nd consecutive week. Commercials have been selling EUR.

Safe havens
CHF, JPY

Non commercials: Specs have been reducing their net position /shorts/ for the 3rd consecutive week on Yen. Yen rose to 106.68 from 105.515 against dollar. While it may seem like a rather bullish reading. Fundamentally speaking japan is in a decade long deflationary cycle. We’ve been seeing yen decline against everyone across the board lately, is weakening much against dollar. While the policy makers are in for a weak yen to boost export and the economy things are not the same anymore as it was back in the 80s or 90s. Now much of the japanese manufacturers have moved their facilities outside of Japan, they all produce and purchase locally. There isn’t much manufacturing and producing happening in Japan anymore. Weak yen to boost exports ? And there’s another tax hike coming up soon however with stimulus this time around. I doubt that extra stimulus will do much. We’ll have to see on that one if japanese economy can swallow another major contraction due to another tax hike. I am still am very much bearish on Yen.

Specs have reduced their net position /shorts/ on CHF once again and they have been for the 7th consecutive week with some minor fluctuations in between but nothing too major.

Commercials: Commercials have been reducing their net position /longs/ for the 2nd consecutive week. They have been selling some of their yen longs. We saw commercial selling some of their CHF longs as we saw them recuce their net position /longs/ and longs.

Conclusion

AUD - bearish
NZD - bearish
CAD - neutral
GBP - neutral
EUR - bearish
JPY - bearish
CHF - bearish to neutral

Morning guys! Lots of posts to catch up!

FE… I do partly agree with you on OI changes I think it can go both ways. Both of you can be right. A good post on OI Peter!

On NZD I think however we’re yet to see a reserval anytime soon at least against the dollar although we’re getting close to a 4 year extreme. We saw quite large decrease in net positive position last tuesday I think it was mostly due to then upcoming election the results are out now - New Zealand’s governing National Party has won an emphatic victory in general elections, near-complete results show - TVNZ correspondent Damian Christie: “It was a very dirty campaign”.

As with any election political uncertaity arises detering investors away for the time being or longer. Investors may have pulled out of kiwi longs and general decrease in OI on kiwi prior the election. For the moment the National Party has won the third term. So there isn’t any drastic change taking place politically speaking at least for now. So I assume investors will be getting back in short/long whichever positions they may want to take on kiwi dollar. But the general outlook remains the same for me at against the dollar I’m bearish.

And also we’ve only got 4 years worth of data on specs or on any given currency for that matter I look at oandas chart I don’t think anyone of us has got more than that as we’ve started doing COT quite recently. I wonder how specs net position looked like before the crisis in the US. 4 years worth of data covers after the crisis, thus could be one of the reasons [B]a viable[/B] why the kiwi has had net positive readings much of the time and why it [B]was[/B] rare for NZD to have net negative readings against the dollar. Thats one possibility and I’m sure there’s many more. So I don’t want to be too quick to reach a conclusion on NZD yet.

[B]Philip… [/B]I’ve got one question, you said in order to calculate commercials net position on each currency for instance on EURUSD quote I simply add the commercials net position on EUR to their net position on USD I’m a little lost here maybe EURUSD is not the best example as it is a dollar pair, pairs that we analyze on COT are already relative to USD when it says GBP net position declines or rises we’re talking it relative to USD. Not yen or franc. I wanted to know how did you come up with the net positions of each currency as you were developing a crosses system.

To clear any confusion how about we take for instance GBPJPY as an example. So lets say GBP commercials net position is 23000 and -15000 for yen , relative to USD. So in order to get a net position reading of each one of them for pound and yen seperately you simply added 23000+ (-15000) = 8000. So GBPJPY net position comes out 8000. Is that correct ? What is the logic behind this ? By adding it up are we cancelling the dollar ? If thats the case to cancel out the dollar arent we supposed to subtract ?

And that got me thinking we should develop one for specs as well. Non commercials crosses system if this goes well guys!

FE… I really enjoyed your report ! it is interesting to see whats been up with USDRUB lately since the Ukraine/Russia conflict broke out quite bad. They have been plunging down against the dollar. I sort of wish I was in there betting down on RUB against the dollar. But that is risky, very risky at least for now. Something similar but exact opposite to what you did with the exotic pairs.

On CAD gaining strength on the back of US economic recovery, here’s what I think /I’ve been reading a bit on several different articles and draw these conclusions :45:/


If you look at the graph above that shows the Canada’s total export in the year from 2004-2013 it stayed flat pretty much from 2011 until 2013. Lets have a look at their top 4 trading partner countries.


US tops the list at number one and notably their biggest trading partner export wise. Same can be said for their imports but Canada imports a little more than what it exports to China if you look at the table well actually by quite a bit.

I think US economic recovery creates a condition where we could see CAD gaining strength however, I don’t think its going to be a smooth ride for CAD. It only creates the condition. That doesn’t mean that CAD will automatically gain strenght as we see China worlds biggest importer of raw materials/commodities and exporter slowing further down. What impact does or will it have on global commodity prices ?

When there’s little demand but much supply price will go down and CAD is vulnerable to these price fluctuations I think its safe to assume that the whole economy is dependent on global commodity price. We may argue that US is their biggest trading partner export wise taking up a whopping 75.8% out of 100%. While that may true that will have little effect on global commodity prices I think.

China is a manufacturing/producing powerhouse of this century. Japan has already past its prime in that respect. Same goes for developed nations. So the emerging markets and China no doubt is the biggest buyer of raw materials and commodities. Slowdown in China was probably partly from global economic stagnation look at eurozone and japan I mean except for the US and maybe UK most of the developed nations are in crisis almost. So it goes both ways. I think there’s different facets to this other than just US being their biggest trading partner and on the back of US economic recovery therefore CAD should gain strength. Aside from that the major factor that we should be drawing conclusions from whether or not CAD will gain strength is I think global commodity price, I see it plunging further down /I don’t have a crystal ball guys… its just a prediction I might well be wrong/ so therefore in the medium to long term I am very reluctant to be bullish on CAD.

But there’s seasonal factors that may drive up the demand for certain commodities in this case for instance in the colder months natural gas exports to US could/might get much higher than lets say during that of summer/warmer months therefore that could push CAD up in value across certain currencies changing short term bias to bullish. I’m actually interested to test this theory guys! buy CAD and natural gas during colder months.

Hi rookie and all the other good guys,

rookie, I liked that you included price into your analysis. Shows how much the net position change affected price action. This time it is also crucial that you analyzed both sides as from my analysis we would not have seen that both commercials and specs are on the same side for some currencies. Please change the first “Safe havens” sign above “GBP and EUR”. Typing mistake. There is another one about the non specs first sentence on GBP net positions. It is vice versa.

It was good to read from you about the NZD elections. Yeah, that can well be a reason in change for OI. When I am speaking bearish or bullish, I try to look for the whole board. I did not say I want to buy NZD against USD, especially not yet. But the time might come not so far when we can buy NZD against the weak currencies.

With one part of the analysis my thinking contradicts. Would be good to hear [I]Peter[/I] about it. As both sides are positive for CAD and NZD you take the summary to being bullish. This is a new situation where both sides are positive and IMO why would both sides be wrong? On the other side (short) there are only the small speculators who are usually wrong. I would conclude here a bullish signal more. However as it is a new situation it would be great to discuss.

Rookie, I like what you think about the after crisis net position for NZD. I also not have that long of an experience to know what was the net position before the crisis. Also, it would be great to know or see a historical comparison of interest rates and net positions. Because of the limited experience I do not know if it is always like that Comms have higher rates. I think it is normal, at least I have some books which are a couple of years old and the situation was the same, it sounded to me like a normal scenario with higher Comms interest rates.

Until I have finished this answer I have recognized that you wrote two new posts. Sorry, I have to go, will read them later.

Sorry I have been away for yesterday. I will answer all the questions and post the trading ideas for the system latter today. But for now I will respond to Rookie’s question and FE’s seasonality request.

[B]On the crosses system[/B]
I actually think its a good question that I don’t have an answer for. Testing will probably tell us the best method. Personally I use the weekly net positions as a measure of the commercials sentiment towards a currency and not a pair. But to me the Euro’s net position reflects their view of Euro’s general trend and not just EURUSD’s trend. I could be wrong but I feel more comfortable measuring it this way. That is what testing is for after all.

[B]Seasonal Tool[/B]
I tried to go back and find the post and quote it but I couldn’t as well. I have my own notes however. The idea was that September was the second strongest month for New Zealand and Australian Dollars. It was also a strong one for GBP and CAD (3rd and 4th most strong). I then looked at the seasonal movement of pairs and so that EURNZD and EURAUD on average go down the most in September. The decline in EURCAD was the third biggest of the year. The other one was that September was the strongest month for GBP.

I prefer to do the review at the beginning of each month. But let’s do them now and recap again at the beginning of October.
EURAUD: down 396 pips for the month.
EURNZD: down 71 pips for the month.
EURCAD: up 210 pips on the month.
GBPJPY: up 486 pips on the month.
Total= +221 pips.

So that is not bad at all. Of course we still have more than a week of trading left in September. But the idea of seasonal is that it is just a tool and not a strategy. For example look at GBPJPY trade; we mentioned a seasonal pattern at the beginning of the month. Then in the first 10-15 days of the month we had a buy signal for GBP. We had on the crosses system a bottom at GBPJPY (was at 100 this week its at 99) and that system gave us a buy signal as well. So the decision would have been easy to buy GBPJPY.

On the other hand we had EURNZD short. But we saw that milk prices were going down, no bottom in the crosses and no buy signal for New Zealand. The decision would have been easy not to short EURNZD. Seasonals are just a tool.

On the 1 minute trader system which you couldn’t understand. That was the name of the chapter where Larry Williams shared his trading set up that you shared :slight_smile: it was the 1 minute commodity trader or something to that effect.

So the system I’m developing for crosses is based on the system you quoted from Williams’ book.

FE… I think you may have turned me into a fundamentalist maniac but I assume that I may have to thank you on that later. Seeing the bigger picture really do makes a world of difference guys. I hope you’re all with me on this progression forward. Thank you again FE and guys :slight_smile:

Hey Rookie!

You know what I think? Honestly. I think you are an undercover macro economist professor. You have been trying to stay on the down low for a long while now. And when you get excited about something and do a little research it just starts coming out of you. What you are putting together is unbelievable. I mean I need a degree just to understand you!
I’m not kidding. When I read your write ups, I’m totally thinking your a professor, and the information is slipping out of you. And when I really think about it, you have given a name to yourself that masks who you really are. (rookie) …(yeah right)
But…OK…yep, your learning. I’ll go along with it buddy.
Remember your friends.
And stay with us! We need you.

PS…keep it coming!

Mike

So for this week we have four currencies reaching an extreme; Pound, New Zealand, Swiss and Dollar. The only one that produced a signal was pound, carrying over from the last two weeks.

In the crosses system, four currencies produced buy signal for the pound: GBPJPY, GBPCHF, EURGBP and GBPNZD.
I will also look to see if the crosses system would work independently from the 1 minute trader. We have buy signals in AUDJPY and NZDCHF.

Hi guys,

just for the record: the last time when we got the AUD short signal we were curious if the signal will turn out good. Now we can conclude that the valid signal indeed was a good trading opportunity. I clicked through on timingcharts.com the USD pairs and some other markets, please check guys what you think (based purely on the system rules for testing) S&P500 Index. I do think we have there a valid long signal which matches all our criteria.

Rookie,

it is funny, what you wrote on Philip is actually right. Philip checked it and did not produce for him right signals. Still, Williams wrote it the way you asked. You can maybe look after that. I mean hear the net position subtraction. This is a very crucial part of the whole procedure as all signal are based on the net positions so it affects our results great if we subtract or add when calculating the Cross Currency COT Index. And great that you caught up with the posts on the system and test it already yourself!

Philip,

well it is an important point what rookie mentioned. He is very right that COT only tells us data on the currencies vs. the USD. We make of course our bias based on COT results but this issue is crucial because only being bearish for example with CAD vs. USD it does not mean we cannot trade CAD on the long side vs. other currencies. Thanks a lot for your seasonal update. Very interesting, +221 is not bad at all. I also support the 4 trades on technical basis. Without the EURAUD it would have been awesome. But of course we cannot take it out, that would not make any sense. And LOL, honestly I was not thinking about the Chapter name. You are right, for me it was just the Cross currencies COT Index System :slight_smile: Funny that everything was clear, only we used different names for it!

Rookie,

the analysis were great, I liked them. The one thing I do not get, you mentioned a comparison between import and export in your table. I do not see the import line though. Which numbers do I have to look? (it was the example between China and Canada). Pay attention with your natural gas seasonal long! I checked the charts, many times it did not work!

I can assume your seasonal thinking is good, but there is a 50% shorting at the same time in colder months for me, just like the 50% long trades? Why do I say that? I think to measure the sentiment here, it would be great to put the temperature chart on the natural gas chart. Now, I do not know how that works, but it is an idea. It is clear that in the colder months we need more gas, but everyone expects that before winter. However I can also assume that a warmer than expected winter will drive the prices down, even if these are the coldest months, they are not as cold as in some other years! So the term cold is relative to the cold in other years? For this reason I think the strategy is very dangerous to go long on natural gas only because we are in the cold months. What do you think about that?

One more thing on the CAD. Ok, I see what you mean by commodity prices. How about a long-term AUD/CAD short setup? Commodity prices are the same disadvantage/advantage for both currencies but CAD runs on strong USD and AUD runs on weaker China. Opinion?

Soon I will continue with the other posts…

[B]Rookie[/B],

it makes me happy that I could contribute a bit for your fundamental development or only to understand the importance of it. It is a lot better to thank it right now, who knows, maybe you have later some losses and you wouldn’t thank it at all! I think I have posted 1-2 times my strategy already in this post. For me to enter a trade, I do not only like to trade in the direction of my fundamental bias but it has to match with my sentimental COT bias. I do really think to have a macroeconomic fundamental bias mixed with a sentimental COT bias pointing to one direction does give me an edge! It leaves me out of trades sometimes though, but it is ok. Best example: I like reading how you guys make money with the very weak JPY. I still do not trade it. I just do not feel comfortable with it. I would not manage the trade good. I have a very bearish fundamental bias for JPY, but a bullish COT bias at the same time for JPY. I just do not want to be in it, I stay on the side an I am happy you guys are comfortable to make money with the rally vs. JPY.

You also wrote about progression. I think in the last times we made huge steps in discipline. It is crucial part of success and as I look into the thread I see the following:

  1. you (rookie) make huge steps in discipline with [I]staying in your winning trades longer and do not close them too early[/I].

  2. Mike does [I]get out of the markets when he makes 200 pips and waits until next month[/I]. This seems to be a bit impossible to me. It is also huge discipline.

  3. I do my best to [I]stick to my trading plan and do not enjoy the JPY rally as it is against my basic rules of having a same direction bias for COT and Fundamentals[/I].

For Peter, Philip and flows I just not have enough winning/losing trade information to write about such issues.

And rookie, I do not agree with Mike, It is not unbelievable what you put together. You make week after week so it seems quite believable. And I am also not kidding. And a macroeconomic professor? That is a complete joke. Knowledge only is not enough for that, you have to be quite old too. So wait some decades Mike before you make such statements there! I tell you, rookie is most likely chasing the girls after his gym lessons and not reading macro books! After he slept his 2-3 hours he does his research and uses his developed common sense. That is how it works :slight_smile: But with the rookie name I also share the same thoughts like Mike did so we agree at least at some point!

[B]Philip[/B],

why do we reach an extreme for CHF? Where should I look exactly? I do not see that one. What I really like in your setups based on the cross system is that they quite good match with our bias! So the system produces really such setups which goes fits to our fundamental frame. The last two setups however, huh I find both of them tough. How did you get signals if actually not using the system? Somehow the signals still had to come :slight_smile:

Good night guys see you tomorrow

Morning guys!

I like how FE always challenges all of us. While I ‘definitely’ need some encouragement by the way your words are always appreciated Mike! its good to have some one that challenges your perspective, thinking. And that is the engine and the reason how we were able come this far in such a short span of time. As FE pointed out I’m not old enough to be a professor nor do I possess the knowledge to be one. Sorry to dissapoint you Mike :8: but I’ll keep it coming maybe years down the road I might get there. Enough the rant so lets get to work. Shall we ?

I like that you /FE/ brought this pair AUDCAD into the discussion, going short on AUDCAD in the medium to long term I think we should explore few different venues before reaching a conclusion. And by this I don’t mean you want to go ahead with this pair, and I know that it is just an idea.

In my earlier post on CAD and when I put China into the equation I actually wasn’t sure what was China’s biggest import. But I knew that they were the biggest buyer of commodities. But before we get into it lets take a look at their total import and export line chart from 1990-2014. I specifically wanted to include the years where China had tremendous growth. If you compare the two both export and import haven’t been growing rapidly as it did in the past 1 or 2 decades. The growth for import has stayed flat from 2012 and export has seen a big plunges in between.



China’s main imports are electromechanical products takes up 43% . The country is also one of the biggest consumers of commodities in the world. Among commodities the biggest demand is for crude oil takes up 12%, iron ore (5%), copper, aluminum and soybean. Australia is a net exporter of iron ore & concentrates /52,697A$m last year/ to China. While Canada isn’t their net importer for crude oil China sure seems to be the biggest buyer of crude oil. If you look at demand and supply theory and how it dictates price I think it is safe to assume that economy of both countries Australia and Canada in a way dependent on China direct or indirectly.

Speaking of supply and demand and how it determines the price , lets imagine a scenario where US economy growth accelerates further up and China slow down causes global commodity prices to plunge down even further. While US economic growth could give positive outlook on Canada’s economy /export to be more specific/ now however Canada can’t sell their commodities at a price that it used to in the past due to falling demand in commodities. What impact will it have on Canada ? It’s definately not a win win situation that we’re talking here. While US may benefit from cheaper energy commodity prices from Canada it is going to impose downward pressure on inflation - low energy price translates to low transportation cost therefore reducing the overall cost - /downward pressure on inflation/. Now for any central banks around the world as we all know by know the key measures they look out for to assess the need for interest rate hike or cut is inflation rate and labour condition. If the inflation runs below forecast in this case for US Fed might keep postponing rate hike.

Hi rookie,

I did not say your knowledge is not enough for being a professor, I only said you are too young for it and instead of reading books, you chase girls. This is all okay! So no worries. If you would like a title, aim for a “Dr.”, you can gain it faster! :slight_smile: “Dr. Rookie”. That would be something, heh?

The analysis were great again. One thing: in the document you attached about Canada/oil price etc. There was a part about transportation costs. I do not have the document with me now, would be good to read but we should not forget if oil price goes down and transportation costs goes down it is only bad for the oil industry. Other parts of the economy would gain on that one.

And do not worry, encouragement also comes every time it is needed :slight_smile:

Good trades to everyone guys I will be sitting on the side today as I cannot be mostly at my computer