COT Report Analysis - a thread on market sentiment

Hi Peter,

you bottomr picker idea lines up with my inflation findings. I checked all inflation report from early September if I could see something interesting (was looking for an increase as it would indicate also higher gold prices).

I did find interesting results. While in Sepember and early October, the main trend was still seen everywhere, which is red inflation numbers. However the second part of October and then November is another story. Not that the reports were positive, but surely they were already mixed at least. The falling oil prices might have ended their negative influence and it is time of finally better reports to come out.

FE

Now that is funny! Forex Gump also decided today to analyse a bit inflation! Here is the article:

Forex updates - Global Inflation Roundup

Hi Peter,

how do you interpret the US GDP report from yesterday? It was better than expected, but the sentiment is bearish vs. USD. Besides the GDP, consumer sentiment came out which was quite bad actually.

An update on gold: until now the support holds good, I am wondering if/when the rally might begin. Sitting patiently there.

Yesterday was interesting also for TRY pairs which took a hit. Most likely it was because of a Russian jet shot there. Interesting how people react right away on news like that. I will be interested to see how long such a reaction can hold ground against the main ongoing trend.

FE

Hi FE,

I figure that it will take a massive shock to change what is already set, regardless of any numbers, well at least it seems that the bankers agreed with the above thought.

That post was two weeks ago, I was referring to the recent moves as in Eur/Usd and the push up, it climaxed on the previous evening’s close, that was the set up for the banks’ shorts, price has fallen since that post.

The one thing to watch, probably the reason that fundamentals get a bad name, if the bankers took it up in order to sell it down, after the knee jerk next month there is a good chance they’ll do a little buying.

Decided to do a little joining up of TA and FA, since it’s the weekend and I’m taking a little holiday.

Many TA guys like to look back and draw lines on the charts, which is great, so going back on Eur/Usd to the post about Dudley’s speech and how the banks interpreted same, we need to go back a little further, to the first Friday of this month to be exact.

The tone was already set even before that by Ms Yellen and her hawkish speech, then out came NFP, now looking at that chart and the down arrow, you have to get a good chart to see what actually happened in real time, not a big long down bar as depicted, but a gap.

That means sells not filled, but gapped through - decision time, pull those sells or get price back up - orders get pulled because of FA, not TA - no change in FA so sells stay.

Impossible to get orders filled without price coming up, so up comes price. The guessing part is to figure where the sells are, well they are def in the gap, so wise to just place a sell in there and wait.

First up a 15min of NFP, and the yellow dotted is a guess where the sells are that the poor bankers didn’t get filled :frowning:

Then the same chart, over to hr1 and to the evening before my Dudley speech post, now maybe a seemingly smart a** post is now actually very simple - TA and FA combined :slight_smile:

Edit: the place to set the sells is the round numbers, the 20’s and the 50’s, maybe the 80’s - this case the round and the 20’s, I did also set at 0850 but price never made it up there which in itself was a big bear sign.

Hi Peter,

I remember you saying already after NFP that you expect a stronger retracement before you think price will head down again. That was a great analysis already at that time, but the one now with the explanation and charts is just perfect. Maybe slowly we can also discuss a gameplan for the December FOMC meeting minutes and what might happen at that time on the markets.

I remember once you posted a link from the CFTC website based on some news about the COT Report. I couldn´t find it on the website, can you please post it again? The COT Report did not come out yesterday, wanted to see the update and new information on gold. I guess it has something to do with the Thanksgiving holiday, however it would be good to know when they publish the report.

Take care and enjoy the weekend,

FE

Hi FE,

Fed holiday, they release the dates here in advance:

Release Schedule - CFTC

As often happens your post causes further thought, my last posts were trying to put into forward thinking how the bank algos are programmed, so came across this release this week, don’t really think it will change a whole lot, but still worth a read.

CFTC Unanimously Approves Proposed Rule on Automated Trading

Hey father Peter…
I have a question for ya.
How much influence do you think the Chinese Yuan affects the Comms? (talking about intermarket relationships)
I mean, we all know there is some. Remember back in the summer when they cut rates and all? The Comms all took a dive big time. But, I’ve been thinking, that if there is a real correlation, then why am I not uncovering this? I don’t have them on my charts. Yet. And why am I not watching the Yuan like the USD?
I have even read, very recently, that they will be joining the Majors in the currency market soon. Like in a year or 2. I think they have been approved by the IMF, or something like that.
We all know their currency is becoming a player now in the world. Should we be looking at that as much as the USD?
Do you think the major banks and players are watching them? And making (monetary) decisions because of what their central bank does?
And if so, wouldn’t they be taking the AUD, and NZD along with them?
And how about their correlation with the USD? Inverse?

I just would love to hear your thoughts on them. Have you thought about this? In regards to intermarket relationships.

Thanks.

Mike

Hi Mike,

Bottom line is that China is a user of commodities, at least that is how the market perceives it. The market views China as a manufacturer and the US as a consumer. The third player, the EU a combination of both.

When there are difficulties in China then the market will discount commodities, the big question is why the difficulties in the first place.

Likely many things, a follow on of the ‘credit crunch’ in the US when there was a (perceived) decrease in demand for manufactured goods, also a transition in China from being solely manufacturing to becoming also a consumer. then too, in no small way, the advent of fracking for energy.

Western banks most def react, or perhaps better word is act, to the numbers coming from China, but early days - watch closely Aud/Usd, back at 7065 I imagined, after some poor numbers in mid Nov from China, that a turning point was at hand, price has risen since then, so will it now fall, is there a H&S on hr1, with the neck line broken.

As far as the Yuan is concerned, it’s controlled by a communist government, so will the market embrace it …I just don’t know, only time will tell…

China stocks trader counts his losses: ‘Never trust the government’ - BBC News

Thanks Peter!

I searched and found what I read recently. Check it out.

China’s yuan takes leap toward joining IMF currency basket | Reuters

Hey guys.

Here’s what it looks like as we approach US session


Now oftentimes we have heard or even experienced ourselves how chaotic and unpredictable intraday moves can be. And for someone who’s tried it for a while I can attest to that for sure. But somehow in the back of my mind I believed (or hoped) that there was a way to trade the intraday moves profitably and if luck strikes it can turn into a nice swing position.

AUD and NZD had a good start from Asian session I had them on my track list YEN appeared somewhat stronger but looking back it was mostly due to Shanghai composite I took it as a medium term strength. Then came London, things were as chaotic as you’d expect it to be for a Monday and the last day of the month - month end flow. USD popped up from down below all of a sudden YEN sank as if had been in the negative for months EUR traced back up again stock market correlation Footsie opened in the negative. Then comes the afternoon, this is where things stand.

The secret recipe to intra day trading you ask ? I associate it with no other than the weak and the strong combo more or so than anything. Well its easier said than done. If I (we) had known YEN and GBP to be weak I would have went long AUDJPY, NZDJPY, short GBPAUD. GBPNZD. But as I’m typing this we’re somewhat late to the move, well provided that things don’t take a turn to the opposite direction we may get a chance at it again when US traders come back after lunch.

But how can we know for sure ? Is there a way to tell and get yourself in on a strong/weak combo ?
Well I have worked up two points one for identifying (this part needs more work) market sentiment second for timing

:: Keeping track of how things progress from Asia - Europe can be really helpful
:: A breakout pattern can be used as a confirmation and a timing tool

here’s an example on 30m chart AUDJPY



(here’s a pattern a long signal that I’ve noticed on almost every pair on every time frame but there’s a catch, it doesn’t always have to be accurate sometimes there’s a pullback after the initial breakout especially if the breakout happened during Asian session but combined with strong/weak combo I learned that this can be a great method in fine tuning the entry not only that getting in right when the momentum is high = quick profits its a good thing if you’re a day trader.

Now the problem is how do we know for sure ? In my personal experience I was on the screen when all of this happened, AUDJPY breakout , similar pattern on CADJPY presumably CAD was weak as opposed to AUD should i have taken it as a sign that YEN was going to sink ? (I’m sure there were other signs that I should have taken note that sentiment was changing especially with YEN, Shanghai composite came in the positive after lunch sometime after London open things such as this) I decided to wait on lunch break, hoping for a pullback on AUDJPY and but demand was in and the momentum was there it ticked back a few points before raging up.

All of this wasn’t completely random, both AUD and NZD had some positive data came out during Asian session, and tomorrow is the big day for NZD GDT data a better number is expected so traders are probably pricing in early on. This way of trading means basically going with the flow you can’t go wrong with that, and there you have your timing a breakout alongside a pattern. Now the trouble is how do I efficiently keep track of market sentiment. So that when a breakout occurs I’ll know for sure which ones to take.

::The last paragraph was edited::

Hi Rookie,

happy to see you again. I completely agree with you on the breakout part and the analysis. I have to say though, that most likely Peter is the one who will give the best heads up for you as he also concentrates on shorter-term trades.

I also work on shorter-term strategies to master it, however I do concentrate on my long-term trades. Those are a lot more successful for me. I do a lot of things the same way as you do, but in other time frames. As you said yourself, it is hard to keep track of the current market sentiment (there are many indicators though). In a longer-term trade it is easier as we just follow the main trends and fundamental drivers.

FE

Hey guys!

Rook…good work man.
And I’m like FE, I work mostly on longer time frames than shorter. (That’s two years from now, daytrading all the way then)
But…ok…let’s talk market sentiment anyway. I’ll give you my thinking on it.

For me, I must see it (the market) from the top down. Big, to small.
I don’t see it any other way, first, by looking at the Major / Comm sides to it. Basically I view the Majors (not totally completely though) in the risk off light. And the Comms in the risk on light. If you put the field into the 2 groups, you will have a seesaw affect. Money flows more strongly when the Comms are in control though. Because you have 5 against 3, it’s tough to see the Majors all agree with one another.
Believe me, there’s a lot of different correlations happening at the same time. Like when the Comms are more in control, the CAD usually tails the USD. I rarely see the CAD follow both the AUD, and NZD. (It is very frustrating for me, cause I see it almost on a daily basis).
I can go on and on about those different correlations, but, it is undeniable about whether there is a risk-on/risk-off situation. So, knowing that, is having some kind of edge in the market.
Then what else makes sense? OK…who’s stronger to weaker in their respected camps.
This is what I see many times.
The USD, the EUR, or the GBP, will take the lead. I mean, when they get strong, their strong.
The JPY usually is a follower. To the USD. (Of course not all the time)
The CHF usually is a follower. To the EUR. (Of course not all the time)
The CAD usually is a follower. To the USD. (Of course not all the time)

But, I guess I should retract that one statement I made above. The FIRST thing that should be on all minds is who’s up first for an interest rate change? That moves the market most. Remember when the NZD kept upping their rates not too long ago? And when China dropped them? (Comms lost their butts)

Well, maybe I’m just stating the obvious. And sorry about that. But, back to the question at hand. How do we determine the market sentiment? In the intraday view, I guess you must have to be looking at the pip/% count being developed. I think it’s best to look at how the week is progressing. I will show you what I look at.
Here’s what the AUD has been doing so far this week. 1hr time frame since the open.



And how about the NZD.


And the USD.

Got to run guys.
Be back.

Mike

Guys.

Risk on & off is a huge help. But it can be fickle changing from one to another in an instant depending on market condition and fear level. So can’t depend on that entirely. And somedays you can never be sure whats going on - days where correlations that we know of go out the window - its probably best to avoid those scenarios.

Yesterday for instance was comms day all the way from Asian session through Europe. Major comms split does play its part into the equation.

One thing for sure from session to session things can vary “a lot” but it all starts with Asian session and the highlight is Shanghai composite. There’s a flow. I guess my point is how do I keep track of that flow. Is there a systematic and simple approach to do this ? (I’m thinking there is…)

Here’s what went through my head yesterday after everything had happened

Shanghai composite in the negative YEN up-> Then comes London opened in the negative but back into the positive when Shanghai composite came back in the positive after lunch -> Scan majors and see who’s up against the $ : AUD and NZD is up against dollar the rest flat or down -> Move onto EURGBP then AUDNZD hmm they’re all flat by now I know that " AUD and NZD is about equally strong " and "EUR , GBP equally weak "

Then all of a sudden everyone even the weak ones went higher against YEN. Then YEN must be the weakest a sure tell sign. AUDJPY , NZDJPY there you have your strong/weak or hot/cold combo. Now the pattern….

There’s always a strong/weak combo to trade everyday regardless of the fundamentals.

I wonder what Peter has to say.

Hey fellas.

Well, how about that market sentiment this week so far?
It’s all been Comms. And I’ve raked up a lot. (Remember…I’m in with either the Comms against Majors, or visa versa.) So, I kept my positions open since Friday. I let them run on since then. And wow…am I glad I did. I finally closed out my positions at Asia open Wednesday. Don’t have the exact number yet, but it’s around 2,000 pips. I was down around -400 pips at the weekend. Then it slowly came up. Ended +1570 or so.
It was very interesting seeing them just plow on up no matter what news came out. And then…when the AUD came out with some news at the Asia open, yeah, they boosted up quickly, but then things just backed off very much. So, I jumped and took profit.
So, after seeing things around London open, it now looks like they still have a strong hold over the Majors.
This is what I’ve been thinking this week.
We have a big push up with the Comms, until mid week, then, a turn when we get close to NFP.
I kind of think things will turn to the Majors then. Predominantly having the USD leading the way.

So, now, I’m out of the market. Just a bystander. Waiting to see a turn. If not…then back to the Comms next week.

Mike

We are very, very close to a buying extreme in Oil based on COT.

Hey Philip, guys.

Yep, Comms are still in control (present sentiment).
Yesterday was a CHF dominated day. BUT, the CAD was on their coat tails. Pretty strong. They upheld the Comms side of the equation very nicely. And also the GBP weighed down the Major side of it very much so.
And now, (London early Thurs) Comms are all very strong.

It’s getting very interesting. I’m seeing the Comm side much stronger, than the Major side.
But, is all this the rise before the fall???

BTW…I’m telling you guys…watch China. They’re coming.

Mike

Look.
Weekly time frames.




http://forums.babypips.com/fundamental-ville/66162-cot-report-analysis-thread-market-sentiment-404.html#post733697

It’s clear that Jens Weidmann got his way, also clear that he was justifying today’s ECB actions back on Nov 20 when he made this statement.

Check out second last and last paragraph in section 5 “Monetary Policy” of that speech:

Afterthought: it’s interesting how a little bit of history can have such influence almost 100 years later, it has probably caused some Euro bears much grief today.

this means you do not even update your data anymore?

In the beginning one of the reasons I wanted to have my own database was because Timingcharts and Oanda had mistakes, did not have many instruments and also not too many COT analysis, only COT Index and Net positions. I am not so familiar with Tradingview´s COT Report, maybe you can say some more about it.