Could my need to be perfect or wanting to understand every little part of the market be the very reason I’m not succeeding

Take a look at this thread linked below and apply the indicators as explained.

If you trade the 4H or 1H, that is, you execute your trades on these time frames, then consult the daily for your direction. Place the WMAs on all time frames and see the example in the thread below for how to make entries and where to place your SLs or where to exit.