thaks for your work.
If you or somebody else here can help me fix this ,here we are:
All files installed butthe only line I can see is the blue line all over the graph (no red line,never) and when I move the mouse over it always says:downtrend no matter if the trend goes up!
Yesterday I have a blue arrow pointing up on the graph , how to interpret that?
I am familiar with cowabunga system and would be nice to use this indicator.
thanks again ybop01- arte U the same ybop from dx4all?
Hi ybop01,thanks for indicator, i have also troubles, for me work just for long position i see just blue arrows.Please let me to know what i must to do to fix it.
Thank you in advance!
Cris
i have been testing the cowabunga system using metatrader. However on the 15 minutes chart (GBP/USD) from 19 april till now, there are way too much false signals coming through. There are 9 signals in my chart ( 2 long and 7 short position), but none :eek: seems to be the correct signal to enter the trade. Isit just me or something else. Please help!!
I posted a couple of questions to ybop01 but he doesnāt seem to have logged in for a while. Can anyone else in the forum help please ?
I have the indicator installed and working i get alerts and the indicator is showin trends etc, But I have notices a couple of things that lead me to the questions below:
I seem to get the alert on the next full candle after the EMA, Is this deliberate? It sometimes means that an opportunity is a good 10 pips lower than it might have been if I examined the alert at the crossover and traded it straight away. Iām still new, but know that some traders just prefer to trade the next candle after an EMA, I might like the chance to get in a bit earlier. Iām still trading demo so not really sure about my style yet
The other question is related to the trend. I have been stopped out a couple of times following a long indicator while the 4hr chart shows a ādown trendā over a couple of days. In fact the chart has not shown me a down trend at, all is all still up and only long trades. Soā¦ how is the trend calculated and is the trend Iām seeing consistent with what you are etc?
Hi dear friend, Iāve just downloaded your ED and tryed to put it on my chart but nothing happens ā¦ I see nothing ā¦ you know why? May you help meā??? THANK YOU
I installed the indicator as told but I could only see the red and blue line in GBP/USD M15 chart. There was no sell signals as mentioned. Tried unzip and restart the MT4 a few times, still the same.
There appears to be a problem with the MACD shipped as standard in MT4 (and the iMACD function which is used in the Cowabunga MT4 Indicator).
I have partly found the solution:
MACD displays wrong in MT4, various people have re-written the MACD indicator and I have downloaded them and found that they work fine and match the MACD in Pip Surferās Charts (and all other charting software).
I can post a corrected MACD indicator if anyone wants one.
The remaining problem is that the Cowabunga MT4 Indicator (kindly written by ybop01) uses the iMACD() function, which seems to have the same problem as the standard MACD indicator that is shipped with MT4.
In my opinion, this explains why I find that ybop01ās custom indicator doesnāt always find the same buy/sell signals as those given in Pip Surferās daily reports (because it is using a bad MACD function - rather than solely because the data feeds differ slightly from broker to broker).
Has anyone else been having this problem with MACD and the Cowabunga Indicator?
Andā¦ has anyone found a solution, if so, what a hero you are and please let me know.
You donāt really need my attached updated MACD indicators because I have now found out that the MACD Histogram is already available in MT4 as the custom indicator called OsMA (shipped with MT4). They obviously wanted it in a separate file for some reason. Please note that the indicator that they call MACD somewhat confusingly shows the first MACD line as a histogram (rather than a line) and omits the real histogram.
You donāt need the two MACD lines for Cowabunga just the MACD Histogram but if you want to insist on displaying all 3 in one place then here are some custom indicators giving them all combined:
MACDcorrect.MT4 for 2 the MACD lines plus histogram. This one is strictly accurate.
MACD1.MT4 (zipped) same as above but with elongated histogram to make it more readable.
I have also amended the cowabunga indicator written originally by ybop01. It wrongly used the iMACD function instead of the iOsMA function and thus seemed to miss some obvious cowabunga signals to trade. Filename COWABUNGA2.MT4 (zipped).
For anyone who remembers, MACD is composed of 3 things: the first should be a line representing the difference between two moving averages (periods 12 and 26 EMA for cowabunga) in MT4ās standard MACD indicator this is confusingly displayed as a histogram, most people expect to see it as a line. The second is another slower line representing the 9 period SMA of the first line (shown correctly as a line in MT4ās MACD). Thirdly is a histogram representing the difference of the first two lines (not shown at all in MT4ās MACD indicator, you must use the OsMA indicator to see it).
I hope that clears this all up.
I would be glad of some feedback from anyone. Particularly anyone who has tried the original Cowabunga indicator and upgrades to this new version. There may still be improvements that can be made, it looks pretty accurate to me now, but it would be nice to hear your results (donāt sue me if you lose!!!)
As a slight update, I would recommend you to get rid of the last two MACD indicators that I posted as they were not entirely accurate due to rounding errors. I have attached a replacement indicator (MACD-Combine.MT4), this is totally accurate to more decimal places and of course it has the 2 MACD lines and Histogram. The values used in this indicator are also a perfect match for the values used in the OsMA and MACD indicators that ship as standard with MT4 (it is basically those combined into a single indicator chart) and will therefore be a perfect match for the values in the Cowabunga indicator because Cowanbunga takes its values from the MT4 functions iMACD and iOsMA.
However as I said before, you donāt really need this combined indicator, you just need OsMA, PipSurfer uses just the Histogram on his chart.
I noticed that the Cowabunga indicator is currently set to not send email notifications. Turning this on/off appears to be a simple change to the code. I have made the change to the code and I am currently waiting for a valid Cowabunga signal to see if I get an email. Assuming I prove that emails now work, does anybody want me to post a new version of the Cowabunga indicator with email alerts turned on?
Yes, if you could post the updated indicator with the email notification it would be greatly appreciated. I will be back testing this system and comparing it to the final results given by BigPipin.
This will be a huge time saver for me and others if it works.
Thanks for taking the time to weed out the cracks.
Here is the newly improved Cowabunga indicator (also recently posted in the main Cowabunga thread, but from now on Iāll just post them in this thread instead):
It should work on any pair (15 minute chart only).
It will email alerts.
It also plays a sound when the alert occurs (email.wav)
It also includes the earlier bug fix for the MACD Histogram aspect.
Oh and here is a Cowabunga chart template too, to make it quick for you to set up all those 15 minute charts. (For each one you need to open a new chart, change the period to 15 min and then simply load the template).
I am turning into a goldmine of cool stuff or what!!!
Ammar, it would be very helpful if you would post your back testing results when completed ;), thanks.
Could someone please help me? I am very confusedā¦ How do I set up alerts for the Cowabunga system?
I am using FXCM Trading Stationā¦ Or do I have to use MT4? How do I configure either one to issue alerts?? Thanks!
The files that generate alerts that I have posted in this thread are very specifically for MT4 software. I understand that FXCM do not offer MT4 but may do so in the future, I donāt know if the FXCM Trading Station offers complex alerts.
The solution that I can suggest is to open a demo account with a broker who offers MT4 software (ODL, Alpari, etc there are plenty), then download my indicator and template and take it from there.
