How to Measure a Good Trader?

Risk management is an important part of a successful trading journey. The method is to determine and assess the level of risk related to the market movement, then accept or minimize that risk. Profit Factor, Drawdown, Risk of Ruin, Standard Deviation, and Sharpe Ratio are some of the most popular methods to measure a trader’s trading risks.

1. Profit Factor

It is the ratio of the profit amount compared to the loss amount. For example, on your last 10 trades, suppose you have profited $2000 from your 7 trades and lost $700 on your 3 other trades. Then the average ratio is 2.86.

The bigger this ratio number is, the better.

2. Win Percentage

As the title says, among the 10 trades, the winning trades are the ones that will be counted. So if you win 7 trades out of 10, your average win percentage will be 70%. The greater the number, the better.

Drawdown

Maximum Drawdown-Loss per trade = (After one losing trade equity-initial balance)
You must go through last month’s trading journal and find the worst trade where you lost an enormous amount of money and went far below your initial account balance. Deduct the equity for the initial balance of that trade. You will get the Maximum Drawdown.

Relative drawdown-Loos Average Trade = (Lowest equity-initial balance)

You must take last month’s trading journal and find all the losing trades that led you to go far below your initial account balance. Calculate each losing trade individually by deducting equity from the balance and making an average of the whole numbers. You will get the Relative Drawdown.

This measures how much of a loss a trader makes on an overall trade and on one particular trade.

3. Risk Of Ruin (ROR)-

The Less Is Better

This measures the probability of the losing chances of a trader. Simply put, it indicates at what point of loss a trader is going to stop trading. This is also known as the “traders’ ruin point“.

This is a very important measurement for proprietary trading firms because they invest real money in the traders to trade. And they cannot allow a trader, come in and take $100,000 and lose $30,000 within the blink of an eye. That is why proprietary trading firms set a daily drawdown and a maximum drawdown limit to restrict traders from losing large amounts.

So a trader must measure the risk of ruin, regardless of whether they are a prop trader or a retail independent trader.

To measure the risk of ruin simply, is by
Risk of ruin = (1 – (B – P)) / (1 + (B – P)) ^ U
B= Winning chances (%)
P= Losing chances (%)
U= Maximum trades to hit the maximum drawdown

Let’s set two scenarios,

Scene 1: Mr. X is a trader with a $100,000 trading balance. He has set the maximum drawdown at 20%. Which means, the threshold for his loss is at-$20,000. From last month’s trading journal, X’s win percentage is 70% and his loss percentage is 30%. He has been taking 1% risk ($1,000) on average in that month. So, to reach his maximum drawdown, Mr. X has to execute 20 consecutive losing trades.

Risk of ruin = (1 – (B – P)) / (1 + (B – P)) ^ U
In the case of Mr. X,
B = 70% = 0.70
P = 30% = 0.30
U = 20 trades

Risk of ruin = (1 – (0.7 – 0.3)) / (1 + (0.7 – 0.3)) ^ 20
= (1- 0.4) / (1+ 0.4) ^ 20
= 0.0007171
= 0.07171%
which is rounded up to 0%.

Scene 2: Mr. Z is a trader with a $100,000 trading balance. He has set the maximum drawdown at 20%. Which means, the threshold for his loss is at-$20,000. From last month’s trading journal, X’s win percentage is 70% and his loss percentage is 30%. He has been taking a 10% risk ($10,000) on average in that month. So, to reach his maximum drawdown, Mr. X has to execute 2 consecutive losing trades.

Risk of ruin = (1 – (B – P)) / (1 + (B – P)) ^ U
In the case of Mr. X,
B = 70% = 0.70
P = 30% = 0.30
U = 2 trades

Risk of ruin = (1 – (0.7 – 0.3)) / (1 + (0.7 – 0.3)) ^ 2
= (1- 0.4) / (1+ 0.4) ^ 2
= 0.18367346938
= 18. 367%

There is a huge difference between the numbers of RORs. Mr. X’s ROR is 0.07171% and Mr. Z’s is 18.367%.
Although they have the same account size, their possibilities of profiting and losing trades are equal, but…

Mr. Z is taking a huge amount of risk, which is 10% ($10,000) in comparison to his balance ($100,000). Whereas Mr. X is taking no more than 1%, which is just a dollar out of $100,000.

This explains that Mr. Z is not a good trader as there will always be the possibility of blowing up his account within the blink of an eye. But, for Mr. X, it will take a long time to blow and, as his possibilities to profit are pretty good, it justifies that he is a good trader.

4. Standard Deviation

This is the statistical measurement of the average market volatility. The Standard Deviation indicates how far the present return differs from the predicted historical average returns. When making a decision for an investment, the standard deviation is used to figure out how volatile an investment has been in the past based on its annual rate of return. It is a terminology used for prediction for financial purposes. It is a way to measure how far from the expected value the data is. For example, a trader with a high standard deviation has a higher level of volatility and, as a result, a higher level of risk.

5. Sharpe Ratio

This is one of the most amazing ways to measure a trader’s risk parameters.
One way to measure a trader’s Sharpe Ratio is to look at the,

Sharpe Ratio = (Rate of return-Risk free rate)/Standard Deviance**

The rate of return: the profit amount /0.100

Risk Free Rate (Safe money from R:R:R)

You have a $100,000 account and are taking 1% ($1,000). Your risk to reward ratio is 5:1 = 50 profit or 10 loss. The risk-free rate would be $90, as even if you hit the SL, you can still retrieve $90 from this trade.

Standard Deviation is the volatility and the risk associated with an investment, Standard Deviation is inversely related to the Sharpe Ratio.

2 Likes

thanks for your nice detail. got some fine line. happy trading

2 Likes

according to me the good trader is a trader who can make sure the best money management plan including a powerful emotions controlling ability.

2 Likes

i think there is no one who can control emotions completely, its a common human nature.

2 Likes

It’s all about the bottom line. Profit. The amount of - not net, or ROR or percentages. It’s much harder to trade with very big amounts of money. No 10% (add zeros here) per month here.

2 Likes

Very true, completely agree with your take on it.

1 Like

True, but we do not expect to win in the emotional challenges, however, we must avoid making the same mistake again and be aware that the greed to hold on to the trade for more, the desperation, and the depression after losing these things will stay forever, but the actions should not be taken based upon these fragile and temporary feelings.

1 Like

@fundednext The biggest problem with being very emotional in trading is that you only take a short-view and ignore the long term goals. So, it’s better to accept that the results will not always align with my goals but as long as I’m sticking to my plan I can figure out the reason for losses, work on them and increase the chances of winning.

2 Likes