Hi ,@Piprookie
You raise an important issue here which has been around for as long as I can remember - and, like so much in trading, still has no single answer!
Essentially, this debate is based on the fact that major trends do not occur in markets very often. Therefore the 20 pip trader often misses the big moves whilst the trend trader loses much of their trend gains on whipsaws during the long consolidation ranges between trends.
Personally, I think trying to consistently earn 20 pips daily is far more demanding than it sounds. The problem here is the need for great accuracy on entries. And this problem is again basically a risk/money management issue.
The issue here is not the 20 pips target, rather where does one put the stoploss! Obviously, one cannot let such a trade run very far into a loss because every 20 pips minus is neutralising one 20 pip gain! So a 100 pip loss would need 5 wins just to return to the initial state. That is not at all inspiring for the trader!
But, on the other hand, if you look for a R:R ratio of 1:1 then the SL is also only 20 pips. This is so very close to the entry price that there is a real and present danger of getting stopped out “by accident” after entry on a spike move - and 20 pips is a very little spike!
I think there is perhaps little that is more demoralising than working hard all week to get a few 20- pip gains, only to then lose most of it on a stop out on a Friday afternoon!
The reason why there is no simple answer to this issue is because no one can tell at the start of a move whether it will fizzle after a short time or turn into a long trend.
My own feelings about this are that it is worth setting a target that reflects the typical length of moves on the timeframe that you are using.
Also using multiple TFs can help gauge what type of move to expect. My personal preference is the 4H and 1H combo. Sometimes a 15m chart might help to fine tune an entry or even signal a good time to exit - one needs to be creative here!
Other traders will always prefer the daily charts. There is a lot of sense in watching the end-of-day closes because this excludes, by definition, all the short term day trading.
But I am rambling and am way off topic (even if it is an old thread!)