I think you are absolutely right. It does seem nowadays (along with most things in life) people just want a plug-in mechanical system that will simply bring in the pips without having to bother understanding what is going on “under the hood” or even learning what trading is all about. I would also be happy with one of those but, unfortunately I have never seen anyone offering one that is consistent for any duration!
And, yes, most strategies here are discretionary and therefore of little use to anyone else as they stand. Like i said earlier, that is exactly why I don’t have a personal journal here.
But helping others to learn the basics and develop their own strategies without having to keep on re-inventing the wheel is, of course, a very different matter.
The OP initially asked for best strategies, but is now turning towards mutually helping one another to develop one’s own strategies - which I think is the best, perhaps only, route to consistent success - or what do you think?