Hi Jack,
Reading your question about 18 Day moving average and why people enter above the MA 18 Day,
I cannot get what you ask because no chart, How far the price from the moving average? is it 2,3,4,5 pips?
What is the time frame used? and what pair you trade? how big is the spread?
I can only guess, you see the entry filled way above 18 Day MA because the spread was big
Waiting for your reply so we can know what the problem is
Yes use of too many indicators make you confused you are weak in making your own analysis . Your efforts are limited to see market and think how to find trend. Some times traders act blindly on indicators. See where is mistake . Try to manage trades manually for good practice