[B]If you are dealing with a broker who cheats,[/B] changing time frames will not save you.
The most common forms of theft perpetrated by dishonest market-makers are:
([B]1[/B]) slipping your entries and exits, and ([B]2[/B]) running your stops.
Letās look at why changing time frames wonāt protect you from either of these dishonest practices.
[B]1.[/B] When a dishonest broker causes slippage in your entry, or exit, notice how the slippage always favors the broker ā it never favors you, the customer. This is your clue that instances of slippage are not random. They are part of a criminal enterprise.
Consider a scenario in which your trade is showing a loss, but your stop has not yet been hit. Negative news hits the market, causing price to spike past your stop. You are counting on your stop to get you out at the pre-set price. But, you find out that your trade was closed out 10 pips beyond your stop. The broker claims market volatility made this slippage unavoidable. Unfortunately, you have almost no way of determining whether the broker is telling the truth. But, once again, slippage has earned an extra 10 pips for your market-maker broker, and youāre stuck with the extra loss.
When slippage is actually caused by extreme market volatility, rather than broker theft, it can occur at your TP (take-profit point), as well. That should earn you some extra profit, which should help to offset the extra losses you take when slippage overruns your stops. But, it never seems to work that way ā your broker always seems to gets you out right at your TP, even when a spike is causing price to blow past. Hereās what actually happens: when slippage is caused by market volatility, and the slippage produces additional profit for you and additional loss for your dishonest broker, he simply adjusts your exit price, after the fact, to take back your extra profit. You never see the actual āslippedā price; you see a fictitious price which happens to coincide with your TP.
In the two scenarios above, it makes no difference whether your trades are scalps, day-trades, swing-trades, or even position trades. Lot for lot, a pip is a pip, and a loss is a loss, no matter what time frame you are trading.
[B]2.[/B] When your market-maker broker runs your stops, the guy on the dealing desk momentarily moves the BID price or the ASK price which he is offering to his customers, in order to pick off stops. Keep in mind that this guy has the task of managing (controlling) the spread (the bid and the ask) which is offered to you.
A 100% honest market-maker will set the retail bid and ask based on the best available intermarket bid and ask, with further adjustments as needed to protect the broker from adverse market volatility.
A crook will use his ability to control the spread for some additional predatory activities. The easiest of these, and the one impossible to prove after the fact, is simply āfluctuatingā the bid, or the ask, when it gets close to a cluster of stops, thereby conveniently picking off those stops, closing those positions, and banking some profits for the crooked market-maker. If you ever keep track of the times that your stops are overrun by 1 or 2 pips, compared to the times that price reverses just 1 or 2 pips before hitting your stop ā youāll be convinced that these are not random occurrences.
When your stop is being picked off in this fashion, it doesnāt matter how long-term, or short-term, your position is. What matters is the proximity of price to your stop, and the ability of a crook on a dealing desk, working for a dishonest broker, to manipulate the spread to steal your money.
And [B]your[/B] stop may be just one, in a huge cluster of stops that get picked off. So, the pay-off for a crooked broker can be impressive.