I like ATC Brokers and PGFBest for tight scalping. And when you are looking to scalp, the spread is not the important issue, the important issue is: does the broker even allow you to take a 1 PIP take profit. Ask that first, rather than hunting for spreads. Some traders are still thinking strangely with strange approaches. And after you take a 1 PIP take profit, what will be net profit after commissions? Spread is not such an important issue if you are a "trader" and are confident in your trading strategy.