Brokers in the US

Broker Discussion
1

Folks,
I have read a lot of posts pertaining to the best brokers and everyone is throwing out what works for them BUT it is hard to discern whether they are ECN/Market Maker etc an if they function in the US.
For me I need a broker that can practice in the US and I have googled all of this stuff and obviously thousands of posts come up when googling.
I registered with Oanda practice account and know they are a Market Maker.
What other Brokers in the US do ECN? I would really like to compare them both.
From what I understand…MM can see your Stops and that can work against you while ECN cannot see your Stops. Is that true? Obviously if you have your Stops set up like 5 or 10 pips away it is easy to defeat your system of trading.
Anyway I tried to find a list of US Brokers that are registered under NFA for example…and there are a plethora of offerings over the internet. It is hard to find out which one is a MM or ECN etc.
I know it is best to jump right in yet I am investigating this topic. I think FXCM was one of those US brokers that many people like but they are now off shore brokers.
With that said…what US Registered and regulated NFA brokers are good for us US citizens? Offer thesr brokers up and state if they are MM or ECN and I will look into this.
Thanks all!

2

No it’s not true to the best of my understanding.

3

Hi @blueridge,

Whether your broker can see your stops has nothing to do with them being a market maker or not. Rather, it has to do with whether your stop orders rest server side or terminal side. If your stop rests server side, then your broker can see your order. If your stop rests terminal side, then your broker cannot see your order.

If you use the default stop order functionality built into most trading platforms, then it’s most likely this order type will rest server side. The advantage of server side stop orders is that even if your own trading terminal loses connection, your stop order can still execute to get you out of a losing trade when triggered.

However, if you are concerned about your broker being able to see your orders, there is a way to program a terminal side stop that will only send a message to your broker’s server, if your stop price is triggered. That said, it’s important to keep mind that, market maker or not, what matters is the quality of your broker.

Generally speaking, you should consider brokers regulated in major financial centers appropriate for your region. That can go a long way to addressing a lot of the concerns you have. The advantage of trading with a well-regulated broker is that there are minimum standards both financial and trading, ongoing monitoring by the regulators to ensure compliance, a framework for handling complaints from customers, and the power to enforce actions against regulated brokers for violations.

For example, the CFTC and NFA set the requirements a broker must meet in order to offer forex trading to US residents. Though not an exhaustive list, this membership application will give you an idea of some of those requirements: Compliance Requirements for Retail Foreign Exchange Dealer (RFED) Applicants | NFA

  • In the US, forex is regulated by the CFTC and NFA, and brokers are required to maintain net capital of $20 million.
  • In the UK, forex trading is regulated by the FCA and funds are protected for up to £50,000 per client by the FSCS.
  • In Canada, forex trading is regulated by IIROC and funds are protected for up to $1 million per client by the CIPF.

You may find this earlier discussion helpful in understanding the different methods retail forex brokers can use to execute the orders of their clients: Who is the counterparty in an exchange?

4

The problem is, all the brokers claim that they are open, have regulators and all related documents. But in fact it’s impossible to check anything, and we just have to trust them. I always recommend to look closely at well-known brokers everyone have heard of. then the risk to be tricked is much lower.

5

No No nO… Hell No
you never trust them

What you do is… in consideration of the fact that you can’t trust them, LEARN HOW TO PROTECT YOURSELF ANYWAY

but… you never trust them