It’s up to you. According to my experience both are winners.
One word: True!
I don’t know who is winner but I Know broker earn more than trader a lot. As you can see, there are a lot of scammer and some of thems earn thousand hundreds a month and then fading away. While I only see a few trader can win millions or thousand hudnreds.
There were times, when traders were able to trade only by phones (I mean, not by computers). They didn’t used EAs e.t.c. And I think more then 50% of traders are using some EAs. IMO it cannot be called fair trade. The winners are not judged, but now traders has more opportunities to earn than previously. So I don’t know who are winners now.