I think the structure is good, maybe a standard header for each post i.e. pair,TF, etc. would help.
Not at all, it IS a forum so there will always be a bit of back and forth banter that you have to sift through.
Pretty clearly, I think you are purposefully cryptic on occasion in an attempt to get us to figure it out on our own, which I think is a good thing, so long as the right answer is provided at some point.
The only thing I could think of is that the charts are not sizeable, perhaps if they were posted as thumbnails? I haven’t posted any pics on this forum yet so I am not sure what options are available.
What follows is just my honest opinion, take it as you will…
I have the overall feeling from the forum that there is the eminent fear of you disappearing, when something seems too good to be true( you teaching us institutional trading for free ), it usually is.
Having said that:
RE: Posting of Real Time Trades:
I would much prefer that in the beginning, you do not post real time trades. I think it is very important for us to learn how to do it on our own and realize success/failure from our own decisions. Only then will we have the confidence to continue trading on our own in the future.
However, I would like to see detailed post(after the fact) trades. For example, after analyzing charts for a few days, or maybe once at the end of each week, it would help if you posted a chart that said, this is the actual trade I took on Monday, I entered here, exited here and this is why.
Some will argue that if you post charts in retrospect, it’s easy to pick winners.
But if we we were to do it this way for a few weeks or so, and then we could all post some trades in real time, including yourself, then I think it would lend a bit of accountability to those of us that are serious about learning.
I enjoyed the real time posting of Joffies charts and trades and I believe that helped him a lot more than if you had told him exactly when and what to do. It’s like the difference between demo trading and live trading.
PS … and again, just thinking out loud here(otherwise known as talking :- ) ) if these questions are leading towards a program/mentoring/signal service, then I would definitely want to see some live real time trades down the line.
Just being honest,
Charles