Hello again bob, well I wont start an discussion on that because, that's not what I do, trading is an infinite world and traders all trade different, so there's no point on arguing about this or that, SR and part of PA analisys period >P
"It is impossible to tell if volume is buyers entering the market, leaving the market and same for sellers. Making VSA totally mundane and irrelevant" in fact, let me repeat in fact you can have an idea by analising the reaction and the background.
Now in regards to price and time, the controversial starts to go deeper right? because you can trade off the 4h charts and make one trade a week, where a trader trading from 5 min will make 20 trades using the same aproach only with time and price.
so I can assume different time frames tell you different stories one tells you time to buy the other time to sell, and that's a bit awkward to say the least.
So to conclude I assume that Tom Williams, a VSA FOREX trader, spent all his life studying livermore and wyckoff for nothing because VSA is " mundane and irrelevant" ?!?!?!
Well the fact here is no he didn't lose is time nor his money in fact he made millions with VSA in forex...
PS - I'm not against other trading methods tick data and PA are very good if done properly, moving average trading is excellent if done properly divergence trading is excellent if done porperly fibs eliots bla bla bla all is perfect if done properly.but it happens I like to use VSA. just that