Edit: to guys trying to understand reality - the above chart was posted by the Commons less that one month ago - the election was on US Independence Day - less than 2 months ago.
If you look at “share of the vote,” a very different picture emerges: Labour got 33.7%; Conservative and Reform together got 38.0%. The democracy is in the counting-system as well as the voting-system.
I am very concerned at how Starmer reacts now to bolster his political position. A weak man throwing his weight around raise an ugly prospect when we the silent majority are the collateral damage.
Plus of course, all the leftist groups, bodies, institutions and not least the Trade Unions, all know how weak his position is, and how large is his Commons majority. No wonder the Unions are starting to lodge ambitious demands: no wonder these are being met.
The thing I am now more optimistic about is civil war within the Labour Party, leading to a backbench rebellion, leading to a no confidence vote - meaning either replacement of Starmer as leader of the party, or even a vote in the Commons. But I always thought that Starmer’s Labour government, if it gained a large majority, would be torn apart from internal demands.
See here lies the conundrum - the British call it 1st past the post, divided into electoral seats - the US have their college - France have their 2nd round - rest of Europe have proportional representation.
We have it here (excl Westminster elections where we put an X to one choice) - it’s great - no.1 like him/her best, no 2 yeah go for it, no.3 ok if the last 2 dont make it - and so on.
Problem with silent majorities - they make no noise.
Edit: Tom - no more likely a bb revolt that was with Tony when he was in charge - they like their seats - it’s an easy life & an easy income.
An issue with Proportional Representation is that it is not a single unique system with the same rules every place and every time it is used. So if a person says they support PR it’s impossible to know what sort of PR they want. A referendum or a vote by Parliament on the proposal to introduce PR is therefore meaningless - nobody could possibly know what they were voting for.
Even if the precise PR rules are set out before the referendum, once a system with variations is introduced, then nobody could know what sort of PR we might get the following year. The possibilities and temptations for the system to be revised simply to game the best result for the party in control of the process are obvious.
However, FPTP is too crude a tool for us to put absolute faith in it.
The way we do it here - candidates are listed in alphabetical order with their political party listed alongside - if no party then ‘independent’
I vote in order of preference 1 to 1st choice, 2 to 2nd etc
If I’m a ‘leftie’ then likely no 1 to the raving mooney guy - then thinking he will lose 2 to who might actually make it & he is kinda half a looney.
All the mooney votes go to the no 2 when mooney fails to get to the qualifying number (based on total votes cast)
If I’m an outright left wing nutter then I vote only no.1 - if I’m a particular political party supporter and absolutely no one outside of that party - then no.1 & 2 or if a 3rd - but nobody else.
Then again if I’m a thinker - I’ll choose with thought.
Edit: sad thing you guys in GB & US - everything in politics is binary - left vs right , just seeing tonight RFK Jnr drops out as an Ind - yet in doing doing so feels the need to be one side or the other.
Here we have a party called Alliance - unsurprisingly left & right dislike them.
Oh they do Pete - They just get ignored or branded “FAR RIGHT RACISTS”
Interesting though that during all of tehse discussions our very own establishment mouthpiece - has not mentioned the bladed instrument endings of school children in his own Country which preceded by nearly a year - but had many parallels with the Southport “TAYLOR SWIFT” incident ! nor the recent attempted ending of a Catholic priest
Green writing !
ANd during the whole time he has been spouting about “Seen bad things” etc and again endorsing the MSM Narrative - in the Streets of his own Town - The Irish Tricolor and teh Union Flag have been seen flying side by side - for the first time in several hundred years ! !
Not a bleedin’ peep out of him about such a joyful event !
Nice thought Tom - but I can’t see it happening - Sadly we’re stuck with it for the full 5 years and in honesty we deserve it ! Let’s just hope we have someone other than the Uniparty to vote for in 5 years !
Some years ago you explained to me the history of “The Troubles” and it seemed odd to both of us that the imposition of the Scottish Protestants into your land by the English had not after 300 years been accepted and that those Protestants were still largely restricted to certain areas of the Land - still with remnants of their Scottish accents !
Your people drove out the English and were proceding to outbreed the remaining Protestants - but still they were not accepted by the original population as “truly Irish”
(My second link goes into the history in brief if any “outsider” wishes to learn a little more about it)
However - those you chose as your “leaders” - have now imposed another similar influx of people into your countries Again WITHOUT CONSULTING THE RESIDENTS and my first link explores very briefly the psychology of the response to the actions of some of those “outsiders” which you seem to find surprising. And more to the point - how the hell did your “Betters” expect their “Silent Majorities” to react - are they too dumb to forsee what has happened ?
Neither he nor I are approving of any of these actions - but he explores the psychological reasons for it in 6 minutes !
I am very surprised that you seem surprised that the Nationalists and the Unionists seem to have joined forces (Something of which you seem to have had a desire to see - throughout all the time I have “known you”) - The actions of your Superiors does seem to have finally “United Ireland”.
Over here in the mainland we have only just become aware that there was any conflagration at all ! - Just shows the efficiency of the Mainstream media in censoring what we Plebs ever see of the reality of what happens anywhere in the world ! - and my post was intended as a comment on the fact that you yourself have sat there all this time - reinforcing the purity of the establishment Narrative - watching the fires burn through your (Metaphorical) window and yet never mentioning any of it in your feeling of “moral superiority”.
Careful mate - your Halo is slipping !
You never heard of Irony ? - I would assume that as an MA you would be well aware of that device - and the second image you refer to surely made that usage obvious ?
I’m not here to encourage any form of violence or illegal action - but I am interested in what is actually happening in our respective countries and indeed Europe as a whole - which seems to me to be related to “The end of Empires” and Migration in general. In fact recent DNA evidence seems to show that we are Not the same people who built Stonehenge - due to the migration of men from basically “the Steppes” whose Y chromosome DNA (R1b) suddenly replaced the Y chromasome DNA of the Populations of England, Scotland Wales and perhaps somewhat surprisingly Ireland too ! - the Matriarchal DNA remained little changed - so it seems that these “Bell Beaker People” - probably derived from the Yamnaya of the Steppes and other similar groups - just came over here killed all the men and boys and “married” the women !
We also know that “Empires” have a limited duration and tend to fail when life gets too easy for the population - which one might speculate is our current situation. Sitting afar and observing then the “Green grass” of our wealthy and complacent societies - and our weak men - why on earth would any young man, looking on from a poor and violent society - not want to better their own lot by simply moving in here ?
“The moving finger writes and having writ moves on : nor all thy piety and wit can lure it back to cancel half a line, Nor all thy tears wash out a single word !”
Aye they are a difficult thing to keep in place - but try we must.
2 things blew my fuse about the so-called unrest in NI re Southport - 1st was the ‘protest’ where guys from Coolock in Dublin waving Irish flags & loyalists from Belfast waving Union flags joined forces.
Then some of them decided to do Nazi salutes - clowns that know nothing of the suffering caused during ww2. My teenage Mum left NI (alone) to be a nurse in Bradford Royal Inf to do her bit to alleviate - and these clowns salute … grrr
2nd thing that caused the halo slip was the pic of the pub I posted - it is owned by a guy & his family from Nepal - a country that has produced the famous Gurkas - a regiment feared by GB’s enemies throughout history - the clowns that torched the pub scrawled ‘muslims out’ on the walls - again grrr…
Edit: there were other ‘salutes’ at the ‘protest’ on show - 5 finger salutes - reference to a particular atrocity that occurred at a bookies when 5 punters were murdered - was sad to see but par for the course.
He didn’t care whether it was false or not - he just wanted to demonise and clamp down on dissenters… He has traumatised thousands of UK citizens with his comments blaming everything on the far right…
Heir Starmer is so far left that anything that is right to him is far right…
Starmer politicised the riots for his agenda by labelling anyone who does not agree with him as far right… Offending many UK Citizens escalating the riots… Regarding the use of word ‘intentionally’ the jailed carer could not have known the information was false… So intentionally should not be applied…
Remember, she was a layperson… Starmer is a politician, lawyer and lawmaker… Therefore, he has no leg to stand on… And no defence…
“The more society denies the truth, the more it will punish those who speak it…” - George Orwell.
@Falstaff Yes… He still has a presence at the BBC… His Statue stands outside Broadcasting House, now headquarters of the BBC… The modern day Ministry of Truth…
A warning to the consequence’s of his 1984 dystopian nightmare…
Orwell worked for the BBC in 1941-3…He would have preferred to be fighting… He said later that it was a waste of time, and that the BBC was 'something halfway between a girl’s school and a lunatic asylum… ’
The more things change… The more they stay the same…
It’s sometimes amusing and ironic that some people on the far right imagine Orwell was “on their side”.
The reality couldn’t be more different.
He joined the Independent Labour Party in 1938, declaring, “The only regime which, in the long run, will dare to permit freedom of speech is a socialist regime.”
His vision for socialism included the immediate appropriation of factories and other means of production, collectivized planning of the economy and confiscation of all land from the rich. He loudly denounced those who opposed “that hated, dreaded thing, a world of free and equal human beings.”
His 1941 essay “The Lion and the Unicorn: Socialism and the English Genius”, describes Britain’s wartime situation and calls for an English form of socialism, which would replace the capitalist model democratically and create a fairer society.
@Heteroskedasticity See here’s where you have it so wrong… No one on the far right imagines that Orwell is on their side…
The reality is very different… The average global citizen just want’s to be somewhere in the centre… This was discussed over on the Political Opinion thread months ago… The United States is calm and prosperous when centrist Presidents are in the Whitehouse…
Not far Left… Not far right… The Goldilocks Zone…
1% of the population own half the land in England… Think about that for a minute…
The aristocracy and landed gentry still own around 30% of England, whilst the country’s homeowners own just 5% of the land… He could see things many others obviously couldn’t…