How to keep track of your trades?

I just track the trades on Excel. Each has a label indicating the strategy, plus any variations re entry criteria or stop-loss placement, TP etc., so I can back-track later.

An interesting find I got from this simple table once was that most of my losing trades went into the red as soon as they were triggered - they never went to a great profit and then all the way back past entry to the SL. And vice versa - most of the winning trades went straight into profit: they never got anywhere near the SL.

7 Likes

I use Tradingview as my primary charting software. I also use google sheets to keep track of my trades and it looks like this.

In the blue Columns I & J, I copy the link from Trading View for each of the three time frames and insert the link. You can then click on these in the future for a visual represenation.

Journalling is a pain in the arse, but then the vast majority don’t do it and that is prob why they fail.

5 Likes

Thanks for your insight. I’ve never actually heard of Tradingview or Google Sheets! Are they both free to use?

2 Likes

If you use MetaTrader you can simply “download” a journal with a lot of details. I’m limited cause English is not my native language so I can’t explain it to you but if you speak Italian, German or Spanish you can inbox me :slight_smile: easy way would be just googleing

2 Likes

i’ve also never heard of google sheets (i think they might be what they use in cheap hotels with laundry problems?)

TradingView is wonderful, IMO

there’s a basic free version, which you can use for ever if you can stand the annoying pop-ups advertising the paid versions

you can also get a month’s free trial of the whole deal (i believe a credit-card may be needed, though: it used to be one of those things where the free trial was on a “book it and cancel if you don’t want it after all” basis)

a better alternative, IMO, is to open a demo account at Oanda and use their “advanced charting” platform - this is exactly the top-of-the-range version of TradingView but under another name, and is completely free with no catches or renewals or credit-card needed - and Oanda demo accounts never expire

(appreciate, though, that TV is a trading platform, not a journaling system)

2 Likes

Even a harder task if your a scalper. It’s a tough job. I have a spreadsheet but it’s work to get all the info in. Did anybody mention myfxbook?

My post on the issue at hand.

1 Like

for sure

but arguably also slightly less important for scalpers (who tend to have a strictly rule-driven entry-method, and maybe a little less to analyse than many of us)?

1 Like

I use Google sheets as well. You can make them as simple or as detailed as you want:

1 Like

Written seems so - well “old” to me, so I painstakingly “perfected” my journald with Excell over the years and it serves me well.
Will gladly give you a blank copy if you so desire.

1 Like

I used to write. sometimes still write some important details of each trade. but generally i check trade histories and open trades details. I forget to write everything.

myfxbook is all I use to journal. I am too lazy to write all the crap I do on excel.

Thanks for the insight. Is myfxbook free to use and can you just connect your brokers accounts to it?

1 Like

Absolutely free to use. You connect your broker’s account and all your account matrix is taken care of…

Thats good, I’ll check it out.

Does it just track you accounts and trades or can you use it instead of MT4 etc?

Not quite sure about that. I have never given much consideration to any other feature except the journal.

1 Like

I don’t journal. Kinda eliminates all those problems.

Everyone journals, everyone takes yoga, wakes up at 5am to workout 2 hours, meditates for 30 minutes then starts trading.

Super weird to me. I just open my terminal, look at targets, place orders and go on about my day.

Keep it simple, but everyone is different I guess.

Hello Pauley!
I used to write them but it is boring.
Create a Google sheet, add (start price / close price / SL / TP/ profit or loss / … ) to that and you can easily have all of your trades. I also use a Google sheet to track the time I spent on social media!
That’s a useful tool.
Best Luck/

Thank you, I previously have been using the paid version of Tradingview, it is great. I do have demo at Oanda but don’t anything else than MT5.

i do not have time for that and i know it is bad
i just go at the end of month and check my balance if it was profit or loss
if it was negative i check my bad trades and review my mistake
that is all i do but if you have better idea please say it to me too

1 Like

I did not do that honestly.
At the first months of my trading I write them all and analyzed them one by one but the I did not do that at once!
I think I have to add this one to my trading life as well, and I think I can use an Excel to track them al!
Thank you for asking that!