Are you asking me in particular or people here in general?
Either way, it is again the wrong question!
If I, or anyone else here earns from their trading, does that have the slightest relevance concerning whether you will earn from it?
And if I, or anyone else, answers yes, or no, how will you know if that is true or not?
In truth, the actual answer is yes and no! Every trader wins some and loses some. The real issue is whether the gains exceed the losses consistently over time.
So your question should really be “can I earn from trading forex” not anyone else - and then put your heart and soul into studying and practicing and learning until you get there. Without your work input, you will not enjoy the fruits of the output. It is really as simple as that…