Thoughts on Scalping?

Below is a quote from UML Live thread.

Pablopluto,

I’ve asked you not to disturb the UML Live thread but you did it again.

Ok, if i read you i can see that you want to point out that tymen was wrong about scalping and its definition. Let’s say you are true. THEN ? Is it a reason to keep posting such answers in non related threads ? Make a real thread (that one was for it no ?) to explain how this works.

BUT have you ever tried to teach something ? It is very hard. You never expect the way students will understand or hear what you say. Then, beleive me, if ever you try to make everyone understand your method rather than focusing on a vocabulary stuff you will see people getting of interest and maybe the general looking at this method will positively change.

If i follow your principles, you aren’t trying to make friends nor saying which method can work or the reverse, not even trying to explain precisely how this works. Then why are you there ?

As far as i can read our yesterday discussion, TheRumpledOne, ECN-Scalper and you got 3 different definition for scalping. There must be more then, don’t you think ?

Can you admit that if you, those who use the scalping method, don’t explain how “simple” it could be (i take your words), then noone will be able to know it. Is it your goal ? Stay hidden ?

The links TheRumpledOne gave are very interesting and you should make a thread starting with those or even making an index of them.

No method is THE truth. As usual there are different methods and as often veteran says, try them and find the best that suits you. That means everyone is different, haven’t got the same time, haven’t got the same goal.

Don’'t you agree that the best way to argue about the method is you, expert of it, define it, train with it and show charts or comments on it ?

Then it would be soooooo simple to answer whoever with a link to the thread. Then EVERYONE new or old (or worse) on this forum will be able to make his opinion and that won"t stay a stupid fight on …i don’t even know on what because you are 3 and there is yet 3 definitions…

Use the power of this forum to show something different. No need to fight, no need to shout, no need to lower people.

Hope you hear me.