True PA trading using MA's for S/R

oops! Am i making a mistake here? i downloaded the pdf file from forexfactory thread from EO Hater "trade what you see-1400.pdf’. that is the correct file right?
please see page number 8 and i see something like
e) 15m-35-50MA spike through
The trade was really easy to take, the resistance and the major spike was through the 15m 35/50. If she spikes that hard through, even if she closes that high, she’s going to come back down to atleast touch the 15m 35/50 before continuing her journey. A positive exit is about 90% in my eyes. I’ve not done the math, but it works.

i have attached the screenshot. Please let me know if i am reading the right pdf file. I have downloaded your pdf also(pdf you have attached in different post here in babypips.)

thanks ken anyway… its a long explanation for my questions. i have to spend time reading and then understanding what u have explained (since i am new) then i will ask you any doubts that pop up in my brain… thanks a lot for helping out. god bless!


Yes same trade , Different terminology. I just call it a cross reversal trade because it (spikes ) Through the 35/50 then the entry is to reverse it.

My Pdf is a LInk on the 2nd post of this thread also a set of flash cards which show trades One candles at a time Might make it clearer.

something to think about



I went back and looked at the chart from Friday on the GBP/USD. If you had taken the Frankfurt open trade when we were at (E) you may have been covered well and added to your trade there. It is worth mentioning that pric had come up during London as normally those moves prior to big news can give a indication of what MAY happen and as we can see it did.

Also we are always saying to use your Higher time frames for entry areas and to pick forProfit targets. As you can see even during a news trade that remains the fact. If you add up all these trades it was over 510 pips.

Also you had a second chance to enter from all the extremes. That is a normal occurence. So if get a late start look for those secondary entries.


KENNETH lEE
Trade Inspiration Not Despiration . Member Since Nov 2008
1,900 Posts


MCFly;Ken nice chart again but I have a question regarding entry B. I think the optimal entry point is when the price comes back to the 5 ema. It would be a textbook 1 o’clock trade when there wouldn’t be the previous candle (shooting star) and the 1 hr 62 ema. When the price comes down to the 5 ema after the shooting star which has tested the 1 hr 62 ema it looks very bearish to me.

Yes you are right, and I know a few people that took a short off that shooting star. But think a minute what is a 62 ema trade it is a retracement trade, and really the 62 ema is not in the right place for that trade. Also we have that PPA line right below the low of the next candle where we would take the 1:00 oclock trade off the 5 ema. Also the shooting star closed above the 200 sma. which is equal to the 50 SMA on the 1 Hr. MA’s off higher time frames carry more importance.

But every trade carries a risk. But your stop is always tight on this trades. If it closed below the 5 ema then we could close with a minor loss.

What is the reason for being sure that the 1 o’clock trade will play out? I don’t think you take every 1 or 5 o’clock trade chance and in this case I would feel that I take a risky trade and so I would stay at the side line.

I always look for first PPA of a retest area after a break which is normally why we get the 1 and 5 O’clock trades. You break a area stops get tripped sellers come in. But buyers are stronger and it continues on after a quick bounce of our MA.

Staying flat because your uncertian is a good position You will soon enough start to see what you need to. It is more important to be confident than to take every trade.

The candle after your entry candle opens above the 1 hr 62 ema and moves up. Now there’s the point I would take the trade maybe arround 5980. Do you think the entry is too late and it’s better to wait for a new seat?

I think like we talked the other day about. The closer you enter to your stop the better your entry. In this case that PPA line and the 200 sma is what I would take into consideration to place my stop even from that entry. To lose less is the same as making more profit. So for me it is better to take the risk earlier with a tighter stop.

I hope you know what I’m meaning. My english knowledge is still limited

I hope this helps, Just remember until you feel you real see PA taking place there is know shame in sitting aside.

Take Care Ken


Good Trading To All ; Ken Lee

iForex
Member
Member Since Jul 2009
60 Posts

Hi, Ken
Thanks for your helpful training and explaination. I learn a lot from you!
I feel 1/5 O’clock is the most difficult setup in EO’s fantastic setups. I have read some of your posts regarding 1/5 o’clock entry point with PA/ppA confirmation, that was excellent posts. And I also understand that 1/5 o’clock is not 100% working. But in the following picture, I have some questions.
1, Is the entry point when price is touching 5ema or 10 ema, or wait till that candle is closed?

The 1 and 5 O’oclock traded refer to the direction the MA’s are pointing in a uptrend towards the 1:00 on a clock face and in a downtrend 5:00 on a clock face. The trade can be taken off any of the MA’s but normally the faster ones. The 5 ,10,or 21 ema as these are the fastest to react to price movement. Remeber the M in MA standing for Moving So price and your Moving Averages are always struggling to come together.

When price breaks form consolidation the 5 ema starts after price the fisrt and the fastest as it has to wait the least because it’s price is from only the last 5 candle closes. And in a strong trend the closes are all near the ends of the candle.

So think of the small ema’s as the bigger the number the longer they have to wait at the starting line. Like in a rally race the 5 ema waits 5 seconds the 10 ema 10 seconds… Then the strength of the trend by how long the candles are and how far down the candle price closes no wicks as the accelerator how fast the MA’s will move.

So in real time you see in a fast break the MA’s turn and head in the direction of the price movement. If the price continues to move fast and the others follow as it conitnues the MA’s start to spread apart because the lower one’s got a head start and are moving fast.

This gives us our trading field. It is also why during a pullback why price will hit a 5 ema on one price movement and the 21 ema on another. I personally like the EMA’s to be pointing and seperated to take the trades. That gives me a better place to be able to place my stop behind the next MA.

2, why left side entry point is touching 10ema but right side 5ema? I mean when will we enter from touching 5ema and when 10ema.

The reason for taking the trade is as with all our trades a combination of factors. The trade itself is designed to let us get into a trend and not be left behind. Think a minute about what is happening in the beggining of a move price is moving from a consolidation area.

Within that area we could have traders thinking it would go short and others think it would go long. Once the price start moving one group will have to decide they were wrong. One by their stops being hit which effedts price and Two by reversing ordeers and changing direction. There maybe even another less exprienced group that are happy for the small gains and take profit.

All these factors effect the Price Action and they normally happen at areas you can see with Previous Price Action. They will be where price was held back during the consolidation period the grouping of candles we just moved from, it can be the last sessions high or low point. It could also be the high or low of the previous day and of course our main Support and Resistance areas.

So our job is first to see that it is retracing pulling back. Then while you price is moving back watch your price line to the left. When you see it starting to hit the tops or bottoms of the wicks of one of any of those areas get ready. That can be at any of the MA’s 5,10 or 21 even the 35 rarelly. When you see price start to turn and pullback in the direction of the trend this is your sign to enter.

But one thing to watch for if in it’s retrce a candle has CLOSED below one of the MA’s this could be a sign that we are starting to get a reversal in our trend. That is also why when trading towards the MA’s we take profit at the MA levels.

Your stop on a 1 and 5 O’oclok trade is the otherside of the next MA if they have a decent spread between them. If they are very tight I will use the Main MA’s the 35 or 50. But normally less than 15.

That is why this is a good trade the risk to reward can be very high if you get it right. Look at that post of Fridays trade 1:00 O’clock Entry. 15 pip risk for a 70 pip gain.

Your Profit Target is the same as if you entered the trade right of the bottom, Which is always a S/R area off ahigher time frame chart. And as seen by Fridays landed right on that Daily resistance area. Then PA started and we got a retracement. You could have taken partial profits then added back at the 35/50and 62 and 200 sma area. See with the bigger values and the longer delay they hadn’t had time to move very far and are all still bunched together. So that was vry strong area and if you had nice profits locked in and a stop placed even with the Noise (News) coming out may have been safe.

  1. in your mind, how much is 1/5 o’clock sucess percentage according to your experience? I ask this is because I have never got a sucessful 1/5 o’clock trading, although I can see a lot of chance when I review history.

I see a lot of comments and entries of 1 and 5 O’clock trades right at the curve of the extremes of price with no PPA confirmation. It is more just a entry because they feel they got left behind and are jumping on.

Most people see price move 30 ,40 or even 50 pips and they get anxious. The retracemnet or pullback that gives the 1 and 5 O’clock entry can also be 20,30,or 40 pips. So you can gain most of those back. But at anytime trying to force a trade is pointless and will cost you money in the long run, Better to wait for the price to turn back and get a little to late a entry on the 1 and 5 O’clock trades than to jump early and find yourself in a reversal trade the wrong way.

In my exprience if you follow the above criteria they are at least 90% the key is to see the PPA of a area if you can’t see a point where price has pushed through and is now on the otherside. I would be very carefull. Take the time everyday to go back on all the entries we have and look for what the others are seeing to enter trades safelly. Run your cross hairs across your chart and see the PPA in action this is the only way you will start to see it in real time. Then when you first start taking these trades go in with a minor $$ amount until your confident your picking them right. Then scale up your risk.

Good Luck Ken

Thanks


Good Trading To All ; Ken Lee

Originally Posted by MCFly
Hello,

I have a question regarding my E/J trade arround 9 am gmt. I entered long after the price broke and retested the resistance area at 134,00. The next candle after my entry candle went above last week’s high and closed below it as a pin. I closed the trade with +2. Needless to say that the price moved up after I exit the trade. Was it a wrong decision or was it only a bit unlucky?

Probably over analysised but here you go.


I just wanted to make a comment about the importance of a proper stop loss on every trade.
I’ve been trading live for about 6-7 months and one of the first methods I learned to trade was “Joy of Candlesticks” with Tymen. One of the things he stressed was use a proper stoploss no matter what…
because what if you Lost power, Internet connection or your PC crashed?

Ken also stress’ the proper use of stops and “covering” your trades as soon as possible in this method.

I have always done this and very seldom has my actual stop been hit. I get out once I see my trade going bad.
Here is what happened to me last night and I am glad I had a tight stop in place. Went short the GBP/USD right at the open, there was a 45 pip gap between the Friday close and Sunday night open…Price went down and I was up about 15 pips…then price hit the 5sma and started to go long. I watched for a while and saw that it looked like the trade was going to go north at that point. I went to close out at +10pips… and then it happened.
PC locked up and crashed. Has never happened to me before while trading. My +10 turned into a -13 pips. It could have been much worse had I not had my stop set.

Make sure you have a proper stop in place for each trade and have your brokers phone number handy to call and close out your trade or take the appropriate action if needed.
Good Trading
Jack

Great advice , Yes it is the unexpected that hurts the most… Glad it all came out all right. I even keep a second computer on line with a seperate connection (air card) . I hate to not know what is happening.

Way to Go   ken :D

iForex; Hi, EO and Ken

Thanks for your setup and training very much!

I am making progress by using this method. Although it is not much, but I can see the progress, and I also can the big progress after some time practise and study. Now I can understand what I am doing, what may happen, slowly slowly I can see the PA.

when trading, we always need to keep an eye on HTF, but normally I would get confused. Because in high time frame the trend is confict with what I am going to trade.

Example: in 15m chart I am going to trade 15m 35/35ma reversal to long, but in 1h chart it looked berish at that moment.

other example like: when we trade 1h62ema to long, but 4h chart looks bearish at that time.

How to handle those problem?

Like all our trades. We start to see them unfold. The higher the time frame the longer it takes to happen.This is suppose to help you by letting you know what is a possiblity in the near future. It doesn’t have to happen but it is looking that way. But we can still take our lower time frame trades easier as we have a idea what our entry area on those higher time frames maybe. Actually making it easier and safer. Like a Big pin on a 4 Hr or Daily chart we know that we can get a pullback into that wick. So if we know that we could feel safe taking a trade up the wick and have a idea where it would turn back.

This comes easier with time. But if you constantly scan all the time frames you will start to see the relationship. How one trade flows into the next. That is why using this system we can trade the longer term trades while taking the smaller ones as well.

Hope This helps Ken


Another point of watching the Higher time frames when you feel you don’t have a clear direction on your Lower time frames sometimes looking at your Higher Time frame charts . It becomes clear as a bell to what is happening. Like right now on the gbp why is it stalling look at your Daily chart…

I am starting a new thread at F.F. I will post the link not sure if it will be delted or not. I would continue to post by places but the chart attachments don’t work well here. Plus nterest here alway wains. Think it maybe to much for very new traders. Most looking for something simpler.

Great Trading To All. Ken

Ken’s Continuing struggle with EO’s system @ Forex Factory

Hey Ken,
I’ll try and find you over there.
I am going to post a chart here. I was attempting a 5:00 trade but did not work out. What did I miss?

Hey Ken,

Here’s my chart from tonight. I’ve marked my entry & exit with arrows. First 3 trades went according to plan. Next 3 did not. I was seeing 5:00 trades.
1st one…went almost to the 21 ma, I entered short on the next candle on the 10ma. Stopped out. I went to re-enter a 5:00 trade when PA started to pull back from the 35ma…Didnt work out. I re-entered when price started pulling back from the 50ma. No luck. Now that I’m nervous and wont re-enter again…It will drop like a rock. At the time I entered these the 1h was below the 10ma. Now it’s closing above. I can look back and see what I should have done…but seeing it in real time seems to be my challenge. Any suggestions?
Thanks Jack

When that candle closed above the 5 and then the 10 ema is a sign it is turning. Plus the MA’s had started to flatten and straighten out… . It has to turn at some point . key is to limit your losses with tight stops on those trades. They are more continuation trades or nothing in this case nothing.

But you have to try them or you miss the great ones…

Nice going on your other trades…

Hi Ken!

Good to hear that! Wanted to contribute to the discussion about your decision on FF but guess there’s no need anymore.

As for posting 15m charts: I think it is of great importance to have a post as soon as possible after the relevant set-up appeared in order for us noobies to see the set-up unfold in real time. Real time is just not the same as looking at charts with hindsight. However, nobody could seriously expect you to post charts of all different tf’s and elaborate on the implications of the 15m set-up thru all these tf’s. Actually, merely posting the 15m chart and saying 35/50 reversal should be sufficient. Noobies must learn to evaluate thru all different tf’s themselves and ask questions if necessary.

As for the hypocrisy issue: understand you well on that one. But hope you don’t mind me saying that outside of trading too one should not be too emotional.

Looking forward to learning from you. Take good care! :slight_smile: