Hi @tomo22, that is the irony . The way I look, ICT/SMC are trading philosophy. They don’t need to be correct, but you understand how to use it. This applies to all methodologies. You only need to use what works for you.
I have met many SMC traders, many of them use SMC, voluntary combine with others methodology.
But when they talk about their methodology, they claim their own SMC.
Such as FVG, it’s said to be so powerful, but it has been patched with many additional “exceptions” to make it work. If there are 10 SMC traders, there will be 10 variants on how to use it. All of them can be worked, but it’s no longer the original idea. So, we have to do whatever to make it work. FVG is a very old concept in PA about range to range. You have to analyze the FVG from lower to higher TF, so you will realize FVG is just RBR, DBD in single candle. Look inside a FVG, you will see RBR or DBD. By understaiding it, you know what to do when you see FVG.
I learned SMC for 2 years, I was looking for a new perspective in trading. SMC and ICT are actually good, for beginner. But I don’t like with their concept about market. Market doesn’t work that way, but for the sake of their marketing, just enjoy their story. Their technical skill, the way to find a structure, is good. However the explanations about how it moves are completely wrong.
Example, the FVG is being targeted. They explained with their concept of candle formation, during the course, it’s 100% success, very simple and satisfying. In livel trading, we hit up down, left right. We get bullied by market. Waiting for inducement, liquidity sweep, we open positions and bang!! … we are robbed by market again.
The proper way to trade is, started by picking an instrument. Look for patterns, and find out how to apply the methodology on it. Volatility, instrument’s behavior will be the parameters on how to use it. So, from my experiences, there should be a SMC for EURUSD, SMC for XAUUSD kind of thing.
So you have to find out how to apply the skill on each instrument. You may proof it yourself by trading with EURUSD, GBPJPY, XAUUSD, XAGUSD, XAUAUD, XTIUSD/USOIL, DE40, US500. Each of them are different type of ghosts. .
So I finally can say, to be a successful trader, you can only keep trading, exercise the mind and action. For example, you are instructed by your supervisor to deal with a customer. The supervisor teach you how to win a deal. When you are on field, all of the teaching are garbage. Supervisor told you make the customer happy, the real thing, how? How to make a customer happy. You need to meet a lot of customers and learn how to react fast and accurately in a split of seconds. You miss one step the deal is off. You react to slow, you loss the opportunity. There is nothing can be used to help but keep doing it until you understand the whole thing.
Example again, when I want to meet a new prospect, I will have to check the person background. I will read articles the person has interest to. The minutes I meet the person, I will assess everything quickly about the person and try to blend him or her will all my skills naturally. These thing can’t be taught but experiences.
The same thing with trading. You need to trade everyday, make it your habits. For example, EURUSD keeps moving down. If you have no experience, you will look for “insights” on how to make profit with current condition.
The truth is nothing can be done. Technicality, we know EURUSD is testing its strong support. We just wait for reversal. Don’t have to squeeze our brain for liquidity and FVG. Just waiting for a good reversal. If we use PA, look for HH, HL. If we want to scalp, look into M15 and bellow to swing with. If the support is broken, just look at our trading plan. Do we have breakout experience? if don’t, learn how to do it.