I will start a new thread over in the swing trading section.
Regard this thread as NOW CLOSED to concentrate on Swing/Day Trading thread.
I doubt they are the same person, just a bunch of newbies waiting to learn. Plus thereās probably a bunch of people like myself waiting in the wings for you to post. Once you start posting, then you will get the participants.
Haha, Andrew I can only vouch for myself but I literally signed up to the site after stumbling across your twitter feed (When you had this thread linked in your bio). After seeing that you hadnāt posted for a couple of days I thought Iād show my interest with a comment this morning.
I read your previous posts and found them interesting from an educational viewpoint. More in terms of how to approach analysis and develop ideas than āthis is how to make moneyā.
ps. I hope the French treated you well!
Thisā¦
No problem Mexicanrapper, I was only commenting about the the recent one posters on this thread and it made me a little suspicious, Iām sure you understand.
I have opened up a new thread over at the swing trading section, so thats where I will be posting now, if you want to pop over there and say hi thats cool.
[B]Hello Andrew![/B] 
I am pleasantly surprised to read thisā¦ as I do so very much enjoy Cat & Mouse. Your idea is wonderful and yesā¦ it is a win / win outcome. I would have found this sooner but I search the threads for ICT and you were using ITCā¦ thatās not how you use the ICT Signal brotherā¦
So before we close this thread as you statedā¦ please outline your terms hereā¦ when do you want to begin? Will you host a thread for this? Or will this be the home for it?
[B]Game On![/B] :57:
Hi,
I answered your post on my new thread.
Not sure what you mean by āyou were using ITC thatās not how you use the ICT Signal brotherā I havenāt read your threads, but maybe I have misread this another way.
Anyway what I suggest is we both open brand new accounts, any broker you wish, doesnāt have to be the same one. We make a deposit of Ā£100, think thats $160 at the moment. Also I think its better if we start in the new year, how does mid-January sound so we can get the xmas holidays out of the way first and see some volume pick up? Iām also on holiday over xmas for 3 weeks.
[B]Suggested rules:[/B]
1: I open a new thread here dedicated to the charity challenge, all of our posts ect are kept there.
2: We both open new trading and funded accounts (same starting amount) and track our performance using myFXbook, tracking widgets need to be posted on the threads home/first page that show running performance ect.
3: Any trading style or methods can be used, and no limits to how many trades are placed in a day, week or month.
4: We make a rough post explaining any trades taken and why, just has to be a quick and simple explanation and maybe a chart so people can follow along.
4: I suggest we risk the same amount on each trade, how does a fixed 2% sound[B]?[/B]
5: I think we give this a good run, I suggest 6 months or more[B]?[/B]
These are just suggestions, if you have any thoughts or ideas then do let me know.
[QUOTE=Andrew Keane;426519]Hi,
I answered your post on my new thread.
hi Andrew,
if you have started a new thread, could you pls. provide link to your new thread.
besides, i am still waiting for you to explain your swing trading method. i couldnt figure out much from your video.
thanks in advanceā¦
thanks a lotā¦
No problem
How about thisā¦
You start with 5000 and I start with 1000 and I can only trade two times per weekā¦ however you can trade as often as you like and use as much risk as you like?
You game?
Why would I want to start with more than you and risk more. But if you want a lead start then go for it.
Since you want to be c**ky about the charity for whatever reason, maybe you want to share that with me, why donāt we actually act like men here, and we both start with a decent sum to make it interesting, Ā£50,000. All profits donated to the charity of your choice. We run it for 6 months starting 14th January 2013.
Are we agreed?
Woooooooa Bubā¦ letās get something straight. You came on here and [U]called me[/U] out. Donāt get me wrongā¦ I like thatā¦ but I am calling you out now. I can and will lay waste to you in any contest and when it comes to equity bub you are talking to the fat cat. You call 50000 interesting? I call it a weekās work.
I am a present Professional Trader and the only thing I wanted to showcase is I can use my methods and trade less and with less and do better. I give away a million dollars per yearā¦ you need to know who you are talking to too before acting like thatā¦ I was not rude or trying to insult youā¦ but we just went to deeper waters.
Itās not interesting until we talk 7 digitsā¦ now here is one for you. You trade the 50000 and I will trade 5000ā¦ yes 5000 USD. If I do not stomp a mud hole in you and walk it dry by atleast three fold I will send you 50000 via bank wire January 2014. Twelve monthsā¦ you get the head start and I get the stage I have longed for.
This is not a joke and I sincerely mean itā¦ come get some. I will smoke you and you have nothing to loseā¦ and with 50000 vs 5000ā¦ how can you refuse? You can even pick the brokerā¦ and my pair I must trade. How is that for confidence? Keep is cleanā¦ and civilā¦ I donāt want you wiggling off the hook and getting banned before the fun starts.
You called out the wrong one cupcake. :16:
What say ye bub?
lol your hilarious to be honest, I would mention certain parts, but all of it really was a fun read. You think an aggressively and hysterical written post towards me is supposed to intimidate me or deter me? I know your game and see through you. And I know what you really are if you know what I mean
I would love to see you wipe the floor with me account v account as I took a peak at some of your vids there and they are fundamentally incorrect in a few aspects as well as theory. Oh by the way whats your NPC number if your an active professional just now, just so I can look you up on the database?
So here is what we will do since you want some of me, we will get this rolling in January 5k each, no one starts with more or less, its an equal start. You want 12 months, then thats fine, 12 months it is.
14th January 2013, look forward to it.
ps. Next time you type a post to me, take a deep breath and wind your neck in. Your a no body and you know that, nothing special. Iām off to bed now, so I will read your rant reply later.
I trade Professionally in my homeā¦ for nearly 20 years bub. I do notā¦ repeat DO NOT want you to be deterred or in any way changing your mind. I want you right here on Babypips where we can see you perform.
You havenāt seen anything and you obviously have not paid attention. I am telling you straight upā¦ if you do not open with atleast 50k vs. my 5kā¦ you stand absolutely zero chance of winning this bub. Rememberā¦ you wanted some of meā¦ and thatās just too much for you to handle.
My terms stand. Your 50k vs. my 5k and I will donate it to whatever charity you deem fit, as long as it is a reputable oneā¦ mind you. I wonāt be losingā¦ and watch my theory roll. I make 100-150k monthlyā¦ tell me what is fundamentally wrong with that lol.
Just bring itā¦
Babypipsā¦ if you have any heartā¦ or respect for the forums and the members reading these pagesā¦ please I beg youā¦ DO NOT BAN this guy. Clean his postsā¦ keep things tiddyā¦ but DO NOT DENY ME THIS ONE!
I donāt care if he creates 60 other nicksā¦ keep this one active for meā¦ please. I promiseā¦ it will be worth it. 
Michael itāll be good either way. Just start with 5k lol I just want to see this done. so I hope you guys can agree on something. This will be good entertainment.
Personally I donāt think he has the 50k to open withā¦ but I may have to agree to his 5k. It didnāt take long for him to go on the fritz and meltdown and the across the pond politeness went right out the window lol. Do not worryā¦ if he is gameā¦ I intend to crush him for even thinking about calling down the thunderā¦ it will fall!
For the record: I will not post anything more. I donāt want to derail his efforts in teaching. It would be rude of me to deny those interested in his materials to distract him from his endeavors. For those thinking I had that in mindā¦ nothing could be further from the truth. I will lay waiting for Januaryā¦ call on me Andrewā¦ I am just a click away.
_
Well i hope you guys agree on something this will be good Iām sure. Iāll be following very closely i can promise you guys. Also Andrew I think ICT was referring the himself like batman meaning you used the ICT symbol wrong when you put ITC. Like the police Chief trying to call batman with that light but using the a bird instead of a bat. at least thatās how i read it.