Inner Circle Trader's 5k To 1mil - Live Trading Tracking Thread

[Satunya]

I doubt anyone is mirroring his trading, if you wanted to copy trades you could go to Zulutrade or etoro and just copy their best traders. You would not copy someone without a proven track record.

As PerchTird said we are told one thing then get another. In the opening weeks I wasted a significant amount of time checking over the trades he entered. I was pretty mad when I found out that time was wasted because it was some sort of deception for what ever reason. I didn’t bother this time.

I spent roughly a minute on each of these new trades and it’s obvious he’s not doing what he set out in the second post. I’m convinced that this account will not make money now. It’s going to be traded into a greater loss then be deleted. Afterwards there will be some sort of big reveal on how it was an educational tool and many will cheer and praise ICT for his great work and genius in carrying out this fantastic lesson.

It’s a shame really that he’s either lying or playing with people. I’m disappointed because of the pointlessness of it all, I was looking forward to seeing just one person out of the hundreds of thousands on these forums post a live account that actually made some money following a plan. He’d be the first person to do so, would have been cool. Oh well.

pull yourself together and stop getting emotional

:58:

[d-pip]

Posted by ICT on 11/17/2012

The Cult Leader of Babypips

[B]ICT isn’t your run of the mill goober on a thread trying to sell EA’s for nickels and dimes. I am going to grab you by the lapels and drag you through a real world event that nobody… not one on the planet has done and succeeded before.

I have no worry about saving face… because I know it will be accomplished.* I have no fear of “fading away” as it won’t be happening. I want you to doubt it… as the shock factor will be even greater than it would normally be otherwise.

I didn’t build my name on the back of wiining a contest using Demo accounts and rolling dice with overleveraged Demo trades. You will see why I am ICT and not remotely close to the majority beating their chests and making claims with no “proof”.[/B]

As NYC’s talk-radio-host Bob Grant would say, [B]the guy is a fake, phony and a fraud.!!![/B]

[woolo]

pull yourself together and stop getting emotional

:58:

Ad hominem

Attack the point not the person.

[IyaJenkei]

I think its to early for that. also when i click the go to post button it doesnt take me to the right post.

Posted by ICT on 11/17/2012

As NYC’s talk-radio-host Bob Grant would say, [B]the guy is a fake, phony and a fraud.!!![/B]

[jonnycab]

Every time I see his latest trade I think WTF! I suppose it takes real skill to trade that poorly.

Maybe this shows how much you’ve actually learnt & developed as a trader over the last few months

[Tassiefx]

Because when its Demo money its nothing but when your using real money and losing it quick you want to try and win it back quickly aswell

It is not demo money. It is real money he has put in there.

If it is a lesson he is trying to teach us, then it is a pretty screwed up way of teaching it, unless it is to make us use our own judgement only in spite of all outside inputs. He has closed out the day -12.4%. I think his max loss was 6% in a day??

I am happy now I think continuing with how I was trading before spending time here. Much less than many others, but I am bloody happy with my 2.77% effort today (2 trades now. AJ long just closed)

[Superdeluxe]

IMHO he is sooo goood that he will make this -10 to +30 this month easy. I always thought hes the best in the world and i think he is. You just watch how NO1 trader in the world shows the impossible!!!

[chching]

It is not demo money. It is real money he has put in there.

If it is a lesson he is trying to teach us, then it is a pretty screwed up way of teaching it, unless it is to make us use our own judgement only in spite of all outside inputs. He has closed out the day -12.4%. I think his max loss was 6% in a day??

I am happy now I think continuing with how I was trading before spending time here. Much less than many others, but I am bloody happy with my 2.77% effort today (2 trades now. AJ long just closed)

Ye I know its not Demo ,im saying he is not use to using real money

[d-pip]

I think its to early for that. also when i click the go to post button it doesnt take me to the right post.

sorry, I fixed the link, try it now.

[1kto1mio]

I think he is showing us how not to trade. Remember that jade story he told. He is giving us a rock right now, and I can tell it is a rock. I think I am learning.

[Satunya]

I think he is showing us how not to trade. Remember that jade story he told. He is giving us a rock right now, and I can tell it is a rock. I think I am learning.

what is the Jade story?

Please show me so that I may learn as well.

thank u sir

[Hogarste]

Posted by ICT on 11/17/2012

As NYC’s talk-radio-host Bob Grant would say, the guy is a fake, phony and a fraud.!!!

Thank you for posting a quote by Bob Grant. I no longer feel old. Don’t you think it’s a little early for this. I’m not being mean, but the contest is only a few weeks old.

[1kto1mio]

what is the Jade story?

Please show me so that I may learn as well.

thank u sir

http://forums.babypips.com/newbie-island/46764-inner-circle-traders-pro-traders-club-2012-2013-series-261.html#post425952

[d-pip]

Thank you for posting a quote by Bob Grant. I no longer feel old. Don’t you think it’s a little early for this. I’m not being mean, but the contest is only a few weeks old.

Do you really think a pro trader claiming 15+ years of success would blow 12% of an account in less than 24 hours?

No, not too early.

[mastergunner99]

If anyone of you still think this is some offbeat education, you really sound as if you are willing to justify anything he does wrong. That’s why people make reference to the fact that this is cult like.

This has become a joke that I’m even laughing. He says he’s serious then flops. He says the jokes over and he’s continuously losing.

Had I invested time into learning from him, I would be livid. I get why you have to justify now.

No one wants to feel duped.

[PureMuscle]

Sigh… Well if I’ve been duped then I am honestly sad. I really do benefit from what ICT has taught me, although I don’t have anything to show for it. I am just upset that things turned out this way. I still can’t shake the feeling that something isn’t right though, but at the same time, it just doesn’t make sense that he would joke about it.

[PipNRoll]

I respect your opinion and what you have been contributed in this forum and so as everyone else. I am trying to weight in the discussions and most have a valid points.

However, why don’t we give a man (ICT) the time that he needs? Why we don’t review the performance in 3 months or 6 months? I am sure by less than a year (this year) we will find out for sure of what everyone is hoping to see or not.

Would you cashing in your Apple’s stocks, your 401K, mutual funds, and any other investments (I am just using this as an analogy) in just a few weeks of bad performance? It is still premature at this point in time unless he already blown out the account then his done.

If anyone of you still think this is some offbeat education, you really sound as if you are willing to justify anything he does wrong. That’s why people make reference to the fact that this is cult like.

This has become a joke that I’m even laughing. He says he’s serious then flops. He says the jokes over and he’s continuously losing.

Had I invested time into learning from him, I would be livid. I get why you have to justify now.

No one wants to feel duped.

[IyaJenkei]

I think everyone can say I told you so when the accounts blown or if he doesn’t get there in 3 years.

[mastergunner99]

I respect your opinion and what you have been contributed in this forum and so as everyone else. I am trying to weight the discussions and most have a valid points.

However, why don’t we give a man (ICT) the time that he needs? Why we don’t review the performance in 3 months or 6 months? I am sure by less than a year (this year) we will find out for sure of what everyone is hoping to see or not.

Would you cashing in your Apple’s stock, your 401K, mutual funds, and any other investments (I am just using this as an analogy) in just a few weeks of bad performance? It is still premature at this point in time unless he already blow out the account then his done.

Investing in the market and speculating currency markets are two different things.

However, if Apple had a presentation and came out with the latest greatest device, let’s call it the iPen, a revolutionary pen that writes itself when you speak to it, and when the product is delivered its a regular number 2 pencil with a broken tip, and then they just say, we were kidding we will send out the real thing now, but now it’s a magic marker that is dried up, I would not only sell all the stock I owned, I would short sell the hell out of them.

[IyaJenkei]

Investing in the market and speculating currency markets are two different things.

However, if Apple had a presentation and came out with the latest greatest device, let’s call it the iPen, a revolutionary pen that writes itself when you speak to it, and when the product is delivered its a regular number 2 pencil with a broken tip, and then they just say, we were kidding we will send out the real thing now, but now it’s a magic marker that is dried up, I would not only sell all the stock I owned, I would short sell the hell out of them.

Apple is a real easy stock. Buy when they announce sell when it actually comes out lol.