Everyone knows 90%+ traders fail. Yet you flops are all here complaining that you arenât profitable. Just because someone gives you a strategy doesnât mean youâll make money. There are plenty of traders doing well in MC and Iâm sure there are also some who are still trying to put all the pieces together.
How entitled do you have to be to call someone a scam when YOU arenât profitable. Get a grip
Get off trading forums and have a dig
Plebs
@j_vdvn what did you post? if it was abusive maybe thats why they deleted it
I personally left masterclass after Pat opened my eyes and joined guerrillatrading which are recommended by FTMO and other IP students. finally getting positive results.
Agreed about the 90% but Irek has yet to prove he is profitable. surely him and his team would be transparent to their students but he refuses any transparency. You must be a new MC member youâll realise what Pat is saying is the truth soon⊠good luck I hope you donât lose too much money in the process.
@PipMechanic
Mate
One look at your baby pips thread reply history says enough
âFalcon fx (scam)â
âTrading masterclass (scam)â
âAnyone swing trade profitablyâ
Stop looking for confirmation of forums.
Soon itâll be âguirillatrading(scam)â once a few kids donât make money
Just because people donât succeed under a certain course doesnât make it a scam. Entitled people everywhere
and your only 2 posts are on this thread. you literally made an account to defend masterclass which is extremely suspicious. Are you being paid? Pat worked with the team so know Irek and Molly very well so if anyone would know if its really a scam or if they are profitable, he would.
He also witnessed how Molly and Irek ethics changed after milking mc members. There is a lot he hasnât exposed.
Like I said before I understand how you feel being a new mc member but soon you will be hit with the truth and will regret not listening to Pat.
More life too you & all the best
Hopefully your next course works out for you
Also this is a new account because who tf hangs out on trading forums? Just going in to bat for MC - free of charge I might add.
What @j_vdvn posted was definitely not abusive - he was raising a valid point regarding fee structure. In response a member of the team basically told him he was âmoaningâ.
Their TrustPilot account is manipulated as well. Look at all the accounts that are redoing their reviews (some have updated their review 3 times!) and in turn this is pushing @j_vdvnâs review down (which the team have now reported - surprise surprise!!)
One of the big problems with the lack of transparency of results is that Irek is supposedly putting together a fund. It is probably in their favour to have a track record of transparency first - especially when it is so easy to provide VERIFIED track records.
To be honest the course isnât even that bad even if it only does teach very basic technicals. The strategies are mean reversion mostly. The whole vibe in the community is focused on a âeveryone can do this if theyâre dedicatedâ⊠Right - To an extent I agree. But there are people that also need to be told the truth - trading is not for everyone - and this is where the conflict of interest begins - the focus is on retention and not on what is best for the subscriber.
Masterclass for you.
No transparency again that this was was taken. Just a Trading View chart posted by Jonny Godfrey. (assuming this was taken) Not knocking the guy because he does give value from time to time. but at least share you took it from a brokerage account to give people some form of transparency.
This is a bit of a read, but I had to let it out.
Iâve been a student of irekâs for the last 3 years (IP & Masterclass) and have been working on my trading game every single day⊠and not just dabbling or trying it out part time. I studied and practiced it religiously, watched all of the webinars, additional videos/content, attended all of the live videos, and simply grinded it out for a long time. Currently, I have not reached âconsistencyâ -Iâve pretty much been just under break even this entire time. Sure, there were some winning trades, and some losing trades⊠but at the end of it all, it was break even or a loss⊠and I wasnât the only one.
Basically ALL of the members have this problem. But they keep trying since the community and teachers are supportive and keep pushing everyone because theyâre âso closeâŠonly a few tweaks and youâll reach that consistency!â
Iâve watched the members closely since the beginning of Irekâs masterclass, and NONE of them have actually gone full time as traders. Iâm sorry, but it doesnât count to be a full-time trader when youâre living at home with your parents. It doesnât mean youâre profiting when you have zero bills to pay, but have cool photos of you trading at beach, or at a coffee shop with your laptop showing your charts. People love to show that side of the game, but none of them actually prove that theyâre full time and making good money.
As for irek⊠all of this money comes from students paying for his subscription/courses. Heâs actually taking the exact approach as Lewis Mocker did back when Irek was his head trader running webinars. Lewis was basically raking in most of the subscription money with his motivational chats while Irek âtradedâ. Well, thatâs exactly what irek is doing with Jonny Godfrey taking care of most of the trading videos and webinars. Iâm not even sure if irek even trades anymore. Why would irek risk losing money on trades when he can guarantee income every month from a bunch of dream chasing students paying top dollar US currency while heâs in Canada banking on the extra exchange rate? Thatâs pretty much the only currency trading he does.
Irek had a BIG, BIG plan of getting of bunch of this top traders together and having them trade Irekâs account or a Hedgefund, BUT, no one actually learned how to trade consistency, so it never happened⊠didnât anyone remember this?? It was quietly forgotten.
Pat left, Benny Lane left, and Jacob Prymicz⊠Somethingâs definitely going on at their camp and itâs not good.
Irek says his course is a MASTERCLASS and that itâs nothing like anyone else has ever seen online. 4K videos!! Wow, itâs going to be amazing. Well, how come no one is able to become a full time trader yet? Donât get me wrong, Irekâs course/website is laid out very professionally and the business is well organized. Theyâre always on top with answering questions and showing students that they care. But, do they really care if they know that ultimately these students are going to give up on strategies that ultimately donât work in the long run? That being said, the entire point of the course is to become a profitable trader, and sadly it hasnât accomplished this with myself or any of the traders who took the course.
Johnny and irek have never shown their actual trading account history. If their percentages were as high as they say, it would prove EVERYONE wrong in this chat room. All of the haters, the doubters⊠literally EVERYONE!! So why wonât they show it? Well, no one ever wants to show that theyâre failing, and if word ever got out that the trading skills taught at masterclass no longer work, the entire business would collapse and all of the students would disappear. This is why, they will never show us. Seriously⊠why not just show your verified trades (without photoshopping them) ??? If youâre that great at trading, then let the world know. It will only provide greater proof of your legitimacy and would further expand your business and trust with your current students/everyone else looking to buy the course. But, thatâll never happen because we all know why.
Their student count is around 700 (with only about 100 interacting), and that number has barely changed since the beginning. Really? Why arenât the numbers growing? No marketing? The students arenât bragging to their friends and family about how much money theyâre making? If this course really worked, the numbers would be MUCH higher.
Unfortunately, their current students will be trying to learn the course for a number of years until they finally realize that theyâve been sold a massive lie. Great job masterclass team! Iâm sure more and more will start coming out and talking about their experience.
Trading is actually very addicting (for the same reasons gambling is) so it was very difficult for me to give up, especially after dedication my life to it for way too long.
I really hope that people who are interested in his course get to read my post and change their mind about buying/subscribing to irekâs masterclass.
Also, donât believe Trust Pilot reviews of this course. All of the masterclass students get forwarded there shortly after joining masterclass so that the reviews always sound exciting and positive.
I thinks itâs obvious that there are some people in denial and are unable to actually see that itâs themselves which are the issue and not the content, the content is fine. You want verified results⊠lol ⊠isnât that what backtesting is for! I get it markets change and so might the results slightly but thatâs your job to adapt and to make the amendments necessary along the way. Youâve Invested years into trading and still not profitable ⊠cry me a river ⊠there are many traders out there which have ground it out for 5 years + before reaching consistency! do you think they were sat on forums after the 2nd or 3rd year bitching about their resources⊠I highly doubt it.
This is a very naive statement⊠If youâve been through the course and participated in the community you would not be saying this.
We all know we should learn from those who are doing what we want successfully but very few will actually prove theyâre profitable. It seems like such a simple thing to prove if you are actually legitimate but Irek, Johnny and Kris will never do it.
I can even understand if you do not want to show your financials to the public even though you can hide the balance and just show the ROI growth but wouldnât you be willing to show your loyal subscribers who are paying you? Donât you owe them that? I have personally contacted a lot of MC members and not one has succeeded with the course.
The only track record I can find is https://www.myfxbook.com/members/Coastfront/trading-masterclass
Irek and Molly is aware of this thread yet will not come here and provide evidence that has been requested to prove the legitimacy of their claims??? I wonder why?
Without a doubt thereâre some holes that just doesnât feel right⊠Been with this community since the very start.
However, despite all the bad words hands down to Jonny & Kris. Just true gems of MC. Jonnyâs always giving his all in the webinars, always on top of slack always sharing information in the community⊠and Kris, heâs a legend truly speaking, spent just hours and hours of his time helping me privately on slack, going over my trades, constantly pushing me and other guys forward, truly amazed by the honest/not selfish work from him thatâs done behind the scenes.
As much as I have complaints about some stuff and the overall situation when it seems that itâs insanely hard to pull profits nowadays using the strats, but again hands down to these two guys that helped me not only in trading but also in life. Spoke with many guys from the community and majority of them agreed that Masterclass wouldnât be where it is today without them and their commitment to do all this work. Not sure how much Irek and Molly pays them to stay but if these two create something together I would follow and seems like majority of the guys that I spoke with would do the same.
@dreambig85 Again, the Tom1307 guy isnât me. With all this controversy going on, I would share results but I canât verify because Iâve used different brokers and capital partition so I donât know how to display it. Can share the spreadsheet of my trades, but then that isnât verified you see (Iâm not trying to make an excuse here).
Iâm a full time prop trader at Propex and trade the MC strategies with them. They work! Again trading has a very low success rate so the guys that say the strategies donât work probably havenât found the nuisances and go breakeven/loss because theyâre taking bad trades.
Iâd like to see verified results myself actually. But donât expect them because itâs kind of an invasion of privacy and theyâve already given so much with the strategies and the live content they produce.
Calm down guys and focus on your own success⊠How many strategies have you created?
Thanks Hyperlax
I was going to purchase TMC black edition as I prefer paying monthly but found out blueprint is not included in that package⊠which apparently is very essential to the trading journal according to other TMC students.
Why do they advertise you get everything you need to succeed? Please consider including it Irek into the black edition. Itâs pre recorded content so its not going to cost you anymore.
I understand charging more for live on going content but blueprint is finished and important to getting the best results possible.
Most courses include everything in the base package. Let me know if you do make that change and I will be your next student 
Just registered to chime inâŠ
Not a big IG user but noticed Johnny years ago and iirc he was constantly trash talking those not showing verified resultsâŠ
Seems the tune changed.
Hi I watched the Trading masterclass 2.0.Anyone having the latest version please give me the link.Or Give me details about the new Swig Breakout stratergy that was not included in the first one !!!
Since leaving this company I have noticed that TradingMasterclass.com are heavy on the marketing. Always extending summer deals, promoting more on social media.
Johny Godfrey has left and started his own thing
None of their students are profitable. Itâs clear they rely on course income and not trading results.
Blockquote Irek had a BIG, BIG plan of getting of bunch of this top traders together and having them trade Irekâs account or a Hedgefund, BUT, no one actually learned how to trade consistency, so it never happened⊠didnât anyone remember this?? It was quietly forgotten.
I havenât forgot it.
If i were a great trader as they pretend iâd just open a PAMM account and let everyone invest in it so weâd all profit together and iâd get a % of the profits, but instead they prefer to sell a course where none of their students are profitable. At least if they had a PAMM their students would be making profits with their investments and the course will end up being paid itself.
To me it make no sense for a profitable trader to sell a trading course, eventually at the very beguining when you need funds but even in that case i still dont get it, itâs much easier to share your history on myfxbook and let people invest into your trading account rather than bother selling courses. Unless youâre not profitable then yes itâs better to sell trading lessons.
