Nice one. âŚcanât see how you got in at 385 though. My price didnât touch 385 after the cowa signalâŚmay be you got in before the MAs crossed on closeâŚie you saw the MAs crossing during the candle/bar and entered earlyâŚwhatever, horses for courses and the trade was a goodâun for you.
this is my timings. which is +4 gmt.
so all news are suppose to come at 1230 gmt time.
30 min more to go. guys packup big wave expected many news at one time.
âŚbetter day for trading the IB strat on GBP/USD todayâŚtoo much lag on cowabunga during ranging days for my likingâŚpays 'ya money, takes 'ya choice.
I have found the problem and part of the solution:
There appears to be a problem with the MACD shipped as standard in MT4 and the iMACD() function which is called in the Cowabunga MT4 Indicator.
Solution regarding the indicator: (MACD displays wrong in MT4), various people have re-written the MACD indicator and I have downloaded them and found that they work fine and match the MACD in Pip Surferâs Charts (and all other charting software).
I can post a corrected MACD indicator if anyone wants one.
The remaining problem is that the Cowabunga MT4 Indicator (kindly written by ybop01) uses the iMACD() function, which seems to have the same problem as the standard MACD indicator that is shipped with MT4.
In my opinion, this explains why I find that ybop01âs custom indicator doesnât always find the same buy/sell signals as those given in Pip Surferâs daily reports (because it is using a bad iMACD function - rather than solely because data feeds differ slightly from broker to broker).
Has anyone else been having this problem with MACD and the Cowabunga MT4 Indicator?
And⌠has anyone found a solution to iMACD, if so, what a hero you are and please let me know.
ybop01 you havenât posted for many months, are you still watching?
but i am in a bit of trouble. Before closing the day on firday i left my entry short open for 2.0323 GBP/USD.
Now its going to open on sunday and i have no idea where it will go. Before it was berish trend i was confiden that i will go down and i will atleast make few pips. Now it has changed to Bullish. I dont want o close on loss
Before i day close i had put for tp of 2.0250. Now i dont know is it gud idea to put it for 2.0300. People what do you say ?
what really happens if i keep it open for another 4 or 5 days. some day it will come down ? Please advise.
You donât really need my attached updated MACD indicators because I have now found out that the MACD Histogram is already available in MT4 as the custom indicator called OsMA (shipped with MT4). They obviously wanted it in a separate file for some reason. Please note that the indicator that they call MACD somewhat confusingly shows the first MACD line as a histogram (rather than a line) and omits the real histogram.
You donât need the two MACD lines for Cowabunga just the MACD Histogram but if you want to insist on displaying all 3 in one place then here are some custom indicators giving them all combined:
MACDcorrect.MT4 for 2 the MACD lines plus histogram. This one is strictly accurate.
MACD1.MT4 (zipped) same as above but with elongated histogram to make it more readable.
I have also amended the cowabunga indicator written originally by ybop01. It wrongly used the iMACD function instead of the iOsMA function and thus seemed to miss some obvious cowabunga signals to trade. Filename COWABUNGA2.MT4 (zipped).
For anyone who remembers, MACD is composed of 3 things: the first should be a line representing the difference between two moving averages (periods 12 and 26 EMA for cowabunga) in MT4âs standard MACD indicator this is confusingly displayed as a histogram, most people expect to see it as a line. The second is another slower line representing the 9 period SMA of the first line (shown correctly as a line in MT4âs MACD). Thirdly is a histogram representing the difference of the first two lines (not shown at all in MT4âs MACD indicator, you must use the OsMA indicator to see it).
I hope that clears this all up.
I would be glad of some feedback from anyone. Particularly anyone who has tried the original Cowabunga indicator and upgrades to this new version. There may still be improvements that can be made, it looks pretty accurate to me now, but it would be nice to hear your results (donât sue me if you lose!!!)
Thanks for all your work on this pipalot. I thought I understood the reason for the different MACD on MT4 but clearly I didnt. As you say the OsMA function gives a reading the same as other packages. So nice to have that cleared up