Also, this week is when I started back on my live account full time and stopped trading in my head like I had been for the past few months!
I do a strength analysis on each currency and rank them between 0 (weakest) & 7 (strongest). Then I select pairs that have the weakest/strongest currency relationship. So GBP was ranked a 0 and USD was 7ā¦which meant I would look to go short on GBPUSD. I have only been looking at pairs with currencies ranking 0-2 with those ranking 5-7ā¦which gives me about 9 pairs to work with. Thatās the first step.
The second step would be to select from those 9 pairs, the ones that are trending according to their strength with HH/HL, or LL,/LHā¦ So GBPUSD should show price trending downā¦and then for them to be in the correctio phase ā¦a pullback up to a fib level.
The third step, is to wait for a bull or bear candlestick to signal the end of a correction phase to enter.
So by that time Iām down to very few pairs to choose fromā¦lol. However since many pairs are correlated, maybe thatās just the way it is. If you get off the train early, you may have to wait awhile to get back onā¦especially on the longer timeframes.
Iāll post some stuff about my losses over the weekend. Right now Iām down about 2% of my account realized. But I have a positive 5% in unrealized gains. my big winners Iāve let run and Iāve cut the losers pretty quickly(after about 60 pip). Some of the reason is because of uncertainty after price has moved. I looked at the charts again and thought why was I ālong/shortā. Which could be because I was to hasty to be in the market. Also from the commercial side it seems we are in a turning point and even seasonally. I dont have a direction on the GBP JPY NZD. just because they seem so iffy to me right now.
Interesting results dpip and thanks for posting. Logically there should be an equal chance of the reverse happening ie. during the week you were up by 2% but ended up finishing the week in 5.4% drawdown. Or is there a real edge to looking at last weekās trading to give you a bias which would make this scenario a less probable chance of occurring hence being ultimately profitable? I would like your thoughts on this.
It seems to me the most important part to this ābasketā strategy is bias while being very forgiving in your entries. This is similar to Cycoās thread with the only exception being that he uses a mechanical strategy for entries/SL/exits etc. He has also been pretty successful which lends additional credibility to this whole ādiversifyingā thing! Count me in on the MG99 bandwagon, will start demo testing next week!
I started the MG99M yesterday and is too early to said if I have to cut the losses. I have only 8 trades open but my mayor loss is in the USD/CAD Iām going long with -30 pips but I hope it get better on Monday. The other trades are a mix of gain and losses but their are Ā±10 pips, itās doesnāt bother me yet
Here is a screenshot for the USD/CAD
Iām right there with you. This week hurt me. Iām too selective and only pick the ones that are FAR into their move so some seemed to turn on me in a bad way and fall of the table. Then my second issue comes in, I hold the losers too long thinking its just a retrace and itāll go back in my favor. Still improvement to be made on my part. The methodology is solid, just poor instincts on my part. Iāll post results and a chart or 2 of my losers tomorrow. Iām glad I had the week I did. Very humbling after my first week. Iām about 7-8% down in realized and about even in unrealized. Iāll work out a few things and try to turn things around next week!
Did you maybe do a fast test if youād look at weekly TF but not just last weekās bar but last 2 or 4 bars what a change that would represent in amount of pairs traded and effect on profitability of your pairs?
Just asking this cause what if you have a monthly uptrend but last weekās price was retracing or even reversing but if you just look last weekās bar you wonāt know that and bias would be then downtrend when weāre still in monthly long uptrend?
There is an edge, especially when the market is trending. Of course there will be weeks when the market shows a strong and solid up bar but then the upcoming week happen to be a retracement. Hopefully that wonāt happen on all pairs at the same time, otherwise itāll be a losing week.
I think that this method would work best if the trades are being closed at a predetermined % gain. We would still have a chance to have a positive week even if the market doesnāt go in the intended direction. Sometimes weāll see ourselves beeing in the positive in the beginning of the week but in the negative in the end of the week. So by closing at a predetermined % weāll hopefully be in profit either way.
Last week I traded this method and my equity was up 20% at the highest point. I closed all trades yesterday with a 12% gain.
They cater to the sad and lonely people out there.
mozdef & jimbo79,
To be honest, using the previous weekās candle was just a quick fly-by-the-seat-of-the-pants way for me to start playing with mg99ās portfolio method. So donāt make the mistake of thinking the idea is a well thought out, researched, back-tested method for long-term trend trading. LOL!
Itās based on a simple concept I use in my intra-day trading, Intra-day I have seen an edge when I determine my trend bias using the previous weekās candle, the angle of the 60 period moving average on the 4-hour and 10 period on the daily. Does that same edge work for long-term trend trading, I donāt know, itās still a work-in-progress
You can bet your last dollar if it was real money I would control the risk. Maybe check the daily candles as mg99, or an ATR based SL, count-back-line SL, fixed amount SL, something along those lines. But no way would I let it run all week without some safety valve in place.
Yeah, I think so. There is a thread buried in the babypips archives that presents a simple two candle break method. 301 Moved Permanently
Itās a method I like and use on the 4-hour time frame. Something tells me it would be appropriate to use with the weekly candles along with mg99 portfolio concept. Maybe a topic for future discussion, method and system.
Is there any software out there that would allow to run some backtests on these strategies?
You would need to quantify everything in the [I]system[/I] but this is not a system, it is a methodology and therefore will be nearly impossibly to quantify. If you can modify it into set rules you could test it.
Essentially a methodology is discretionary which isnāt possible to code unless made into a system with set rules.
hellogoodbye
You have a valid point. I was wondering what impact different selection criteria would have on the overall methodology, say the difference between using last weekās candle to get a market bias v a defined period moving average as d-pip suggested. Iām not much of coder and can see that probably wouldnāt translate into an electronic system.
Phewwwwā¦glad to see that got nipped in the budā¦lol. Itās so refreshing to not see something go through the stages of automation.
Sweet Pips
Iām too much of a control freak to hand something over to some form of bot. I was just seeing if I could ājuiceā the results, honest!
Sorry, I didnāt mean to single you outā¦Iāve just seen so many threads where ultimately someone (myself included) tries to automate it all and the rest of the thread focuses on that, so it was nice to hear that hopefully wonāt happen.
Sweet Pips
No worries, I didnāt take it that way.
Here are my sad week 2 results. Still working on the skill of exiting losers as you can see, a couple ran a bit on me. Hopefully week 3 will be a little better. Thereās entirely too much red on this postā¦
[B]Week 2 start[/B] $49,074.33
[B][U]Open[/U][/B]
AUD/USD Short @ 1.02179 +11.3 pips $30.25
EUR/JPY Long @ 121.138 +67.1 pips $358.65
EUR/USD Short @ 1.30426 +19.2 pips $191.65
NZD/CAD Long @ 0.85061 -38.5 pips $-186.48
NZD/CHF Long @ 0.77595 +17.0 pips $182.76
USD/CAD Long @ 1.00850 +182.6 pips $871.70
USD/CHF Long @ 0.92807 +146.6 pips $779.78
[B]Total[/B] +405.3 pips $2,228.31
[B][U]Closed[/U][/B]
AUD/CAD Long @ 1.04368 +20.0 pips $117.46
AUD/NZD Long @ 1.23159 +24.5 pips $101.95
CAD/CHF Short @ 0.91320 +31.8 pips $143.91
CAD/JPY Short @ 89.334 -95.0 pips $-520.56
EUR/AUD Long @ 1.28499 -80.1 pips $-417.21
EUR/CAD Long @ 1.34673 -118.1 pips $-573.84
EUR/CHF Short @ 1.22770 +50.0 pips $267.51
EUR/USD Short @ 1.32738 +150.0 pips $750.45
EUR/USD Short @ 1.30650 -80.3 pips $-400.90
GBP/CAD Long @ 1.56304 -200.6 pips $-974.69
NZD/JPY Short @ 75.634 -90.1 pips $-500.13
NZD/USD Short @ 0.82441 -45.0 pips $-237.00
[B]Total[/B] -432.9 pips $-2,243.05
[B]Account Balance[/B] $46,831.28
[B]Available Equity[/B] $49,059.59
[B]Week 2 Totals[/B] -27.6 pips $-14.74
āGood news everyone,ā he said in a sarcastic tone, āIāve began coding MG99ās methodology into an EA!ā
And an EA is what exactly?