I really like your idea, and intend to follow at least for awhile, want to see how well it keeps going. I’m not trading much right now, but I’ll try to chime in when I do make a trade.
One suggestion: Think we should start a new thread for each week (or at least each month). Months-old trade ideas would quickly become very tedious. Our friends at ForexLive start a new trading ideas thread for each session, though they’re more focused on intraday stuff. If your idea catches on, maybe one of the moderators here could take the responsibility?