Pound Sterling Futures - Commitment of Traders Summary - 10/19/10 thru 10/11/11
I realize that my way of looking at COT data differs from Michael’s way. I hope that I am not contradicting any of his teaching here on this thread. (If this is seen as contradicting Michael’s teaching, please tell me so, and I will shut up and go away.)
In my view, COT data does not predict price movement. Correctly read, COT data shows us market sentiment. When an existing trend is in place, market sentiment, as revealed in COT data, generally mirrors (confirms) that trend in both direction and strength. Observing an existing trend on a price chart, and finding confirmation of that trend in COT data (especially COT data graphically displayed), is the easy part.
At market tops or bottoms, COT data may or may not “call” the turn, by reversing simultaneously with the trend reversal. Seeing what looks like a top or a bottom on a price chart, and finding timely confirmation of that trend-reversal in the COT data, is the hard part. In fact, it’s basically akin to an art; it certainly isn’t a science.
At suspected market tops or bottoms, we might say that COT data is signaling one thing or another; but, I think it’s important that we not take that to mean that the data is predicting anything.
COT data reflects the consensus of (1) commercial interests, (2) large speculators, and (3) small speculators — who have positions in the futures market. The consensus of each of these three groups represents the average opinion, if you will, of that group — opinion which forms after the fact, after a trend begins or ends. This consensus follows price; it does not lead it. COT data is a lagging indicator.
Michael tends to focus on the commercial interests reported in the COT data. This group includes: importers, exporters, multinationals, and others, who use the currency futures market to hedge currency risk.
I watch the large speculators. This group includes: big bank prop desks (Deutsche Bank, and others), large hedge funds (FX Concepts, and others), and large-cap individuals who use the currency futures market to speculate on price movement.
Maybe these are simply two different ways of looking at the same thing. Again, I hope that I’m not contradicting Michael’s teaching, in any way.
Yesterday’s GBP COT Report shows us the following metrics:
• Open interest: 184,359 contracts — up 9,165 (up 5.23 %) from last week
• Commercial LONG positions: 156,606 contracts — up 7,837 (up 5.27%) from last week
• Large spec SHORT positions: 77,363 contracts — down 6,290 (down 7.52%) from last week
Here’s a link to last Friday’s (October 7) chart — http://forums.babypips.com/newbie-island/36328-what-every-new-aspiring-forex-trader-still-wants-know-4.html#post285294
As I see it, in yesterday’s (October 14) COT Report, the large speculators are confirming that the low in the GBP/USD (made on October 6) was a major trend-reversal point.
But, it’s certainly possible to misinterpret COT data, and only time will tell whether my interpretation is correct.
Here is the latest chart, with some notes which I have added (in green):
Open interest has not peaked yet, due almost entirely to the opening of new positions — both LONG and SHORT — by the commercials, who were (as of last Tuesday) still hedging (locking in) these relatively low prices for the pound sterling.
The big speculators, who care only about the direction of price in the near future, appear to be saying it’s up, from here.