You say the strategy is a loser. I ask you why and then you ask me to tell you why. This is just a circular debate and we’re not getting anywhere. You’re wasting both our time.
1 Like
This is nother task but I think also pointing out scams makes sense.
Preventing noobs to be impressend and waste money and time with something that does not work.
I am not looking for something that works…I know he is fake but not everyone else does …nothing to do with hating
Stop trying to be the saviour of all newbies and get a life - if he is so much of a fraud and it offends you so much make a complaint to the FSA or whatever
Who said its a debate …I told you I knew your username form over the years ,I also know what your like…So I knew I could count on you to keep posting and keep the thread alive .More posts more views more people see the truth …Thank you Tom great work
1 Like
This guy was doing the same with other guru/youtubers… 
From charlatan hunter to charlatan?
Happens often.
1 Like
Ah makes sense now .Went to your site…Buy john a coffee ,same as scruffy
Well as it stands not one person has bought me coffee!
Okay so I see your point - you dont want anyone to make money from their skills at all.
For myself - I really want to get this internet thing cracked and bring in a quid or two - im failing badly!
And you are surprised by that lol
What skill do you have
What you suggest about us not actually having a debate has some accuracy, we aren’t there yet. That’s because you have put forward your viewpoint, you main fact being that scruffy does not trade live, and I have replied that this is irrelevant. In that sense I am not debating.
Im doing my best to be as productive to new traders as possible - sure my sites far from great.
Just trying to improve my skillset.
No If he traded on demo and said he did wouldnt be much of a problem.He is being honest .Showing the demo statements fine too but tricking you into thinking their real is a problem
You are hung up on the demo thing…its the dishonesty
There’s no need to explain, I understand your point, I just don’t agree its important.
But why dont you agree…
I already explained to you - “The only test of real importance is whether the product he’s selling is fit for purpose, not the quality of his promotional techniques.”
1 Like
Sure I’m not disagreeing with what you say - I just don’t know the facts - and frankly if you are correct I’m quite shocked too.
But I always think it’s better to offer solutions rather than hate - that’s why I’m just trying to do my bit with my own site (which you obviously disapprove of)
Ok you dont know the facts
So you watched the video.ye…Fact 1 .he is trading on a demo in the video. Fact 2 .he cuts the video ,if you look closely you can see it .I explained the account number change and the excel download change
So do you agree with those facts
I dont diapprove of your site…Have you been dishonest
Like with the analogy I put to Tom.If you are selling fake gucci bags and the customer knows thats fine but if you are saying they are real its dishonest
I do think so