This guy was doing the same with other guru/youtubers… 
From charlatan hunter to charlatan?
Happens often.
1 Like
Ah makes sense now .Went to your site…Buy john a coffee ,same as scruffy
Well as it stands not one person has bought me coffee!
Okay so I see your point - you dont want anyone to make money from their skills at all.
For myself - I really want to get this internet thing cracked and bring in a quid or two - im failing badly!
And you are surprised by that lol
What skill do you have
What you suggest about us not actually having a debate has some accuracy, we aren’t there yet. That’s because you have put forward your viewpoint, you main fact being that scruffy does not trade live, and I have replied that this is irrelevant. In that sense I am not debating.
Im doing my best to be as productive to new traders as possible - sure my sites far from great.
Just trying to improve my skillset.
No If he traded on demo and said he did wouldnt be much of a problem.He is being honest .Showing the demo statements fine too but tricking you into thinking their real is a problem
You are hung up on the demo thing…its the dishonesty
There’s no need to explain, I understand your point, I just don’t agree its important.
But why dont you agree…
I already explained to you - “The only test of real importance is whether the product he’s selling is fit for purpose, not the quality of his promotional techniques.”
1 Like
Sure I’m not disagreeing with what you say - I just don’t know the facts - and frankly if you are correct I’m quite shocked too.
But I always think it’s better to offer solutions rather than hate - that’s why I’m just trying to do my bit with my own site (which you obviously disapprove of)
Ok you dont know the facts
So you watched the video.ye…Fact 1 .he is trading on a demo in the video. Fact 2 .he cuts the video ,if you look closely you can see it .I explained the account number change and the excel download change
So do you agree with those facts
I dont diapprove of your site…Have you been dishonest
Like with the analogy I put to Tom.If you are selling fake gucci bags and the customer knows thats fine but if you are saying they are real its dishonest
I do think so
So what has you doubting them
The purpose is to make pips, and it is the seller that has to prove that it happens with a live verified trackrecord, one year on myfxbook could be a good start.
Not sure your meaning
I try to be as honest with my site as possible - granted I don’t show screenshots of the many losers I’ve had - I may to at some point.
But I always say trading is hard, and that I made a right hash of it for many years.
Thats what I am saying .Its just a blog really and you say buy me a coffee …no harm
If you are posting videos claiming you make thousands do you think you would get a few coffee`s then
You said offer solutions ok
Gary @lang15…Would you please come and solve this discussion for us please .You have no problem showing you records on every video. you post a view of the days history.For 1 day only make the URL visible when you are trading normally £25 a point